forum.stripovi.com
forum.stripovi.com
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Active Polls | Aukcije | Private Messages | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
 Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Stripovi
 Bonelli
 Carsonova prošlost (Tex) VS Zimska Zmija (Zagor)		  New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Topic Locked
Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 5

Bruce Springsteen
Advanced Member



5545 Posts

Member since 28/10/2008

Posted - 03/09/2009 : 23:33:15  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Bruce Springsteen a Private Message
U ovom slucaju suprostavice se dva najdugovecnija Bonelli junaka Zagor i Tex Willer, odnosno njihove price. Po komentarima na recenzijama naj pirca Texa “Carsonova prošlost”, i sa druge strane po izboru forumaša druga prica Zagora, ali najbolja realna prica “Zimska zmija”.

Surovi pravi realni western “Carsonova prošlost” protiv surovog realnog Divljeg zapada u “Zimskoj Zmiji”.

1. Carsonova prošlost (Tex Willer) – br. orig. 407-409 (kod nas SD 38-40)
( Boselli / Marcello)

VS

2. Zimska Zmija (Zagor) – br.orig. 112-116 (kod nas ZS 336-338, 340-341 I ZG LEX 119-123)
(Nolitta / Ferri – Bignotti)

Glasanje bez polla, poželjan komentar.

Kit Carson
Advanced Member



Serbia
11593 Posts

Member since 19/11/2008

Posted - 03/09/2009 : 23:35:10  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Kit Carson a Private Message
U jbt, ovo ce ici na penale.
Ubrzajte Texa u koloru na 2 mesecno!
Go to Top of Page

---dp---
Advanced Member

17232 Posts

Member since 26/10/2001

Posted - 03/09/2009 : 23:39:35  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send ---dp--- a Private Message
Zimska zmija, naravno... ne zato sto je Zagor, vec zaista
Go to Top of Page

Billy_the_Kid
Senior Member



1518 Posts

Member since 02/06/2005

Posted - 03/09/2009 : 23:43:33  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit Billy_the_Kid's Homepage  Send Billy_the_Kid a Private Message
U kolekciji imam vise Zagora al u ovoj kombinaciji Tex pobjedjuje jednim cvrstim nokautom koji protivnika salje na suprotan kraj sobe, hehehe. Ne, ozbiljno Carsonova proslost je puno bolje smisljena, da ne kazem sto me smeta u Zimskoj zmiji ona promjena crtaca... gubi se ugodjaj
Seeing things differently can open new paths.
Go to Top of Page

Bruce Springsteen
Advanced Member



5545 Posts

Member since 28/10/2008

Posted - 03/09/2009 : 23:55:57  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Bruce Springsteen a Private Message
quote:
Originally posted by Kit Carson

U jbt, ovo ce ici na penale.


Razumecu te ako si subjektivan, jer teško je glasati protiv sebe
Go to Top of Page

kandraks
Advanced Member



Bosnia and Herzegovina
3914 Posts

Member since 16/03/2009

Posted - 03/09/2009 : 23:57:26  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send kandraks a Private Message
Definitivno ,,Zimska Zmija,,!!!
Dagda, Gospodaru Noci, obasjaj svoga slugu jer on ce zlatnim srpom Druida ubrati Svetu Imelu koja otvara Vrata Nadnaravnog Svijeta...Vrata koja vode do Bogova!!!
Go to Top of Page

cibalia
Senior Member



Sierra Leone
1699 Posts

Member since 14/11/2008

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 00:02:56  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit cibalia's Homepage  Send cibalia a Private Message
Carsonova prošlost!
U vlaku sam završio u istom vagonu s profesorom-inzom. Poceo mi je pricati o Zagorovim recenzijama, Zagorovim fanovima i autorima, te o Zagoru opcenito. Nakon 10 minuta sam se bacio pod tracnice...
Go to Top of Page

goksi
Senior Member

Serbia
1950 Posts

Member since 15/04/2007

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 00:03:08  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send goksi a Private Message
Dajte bazen™, necu da glasam javno.
Go to Top of Page

King Warrior
stripovi.com suradnik



22315 Posts

Member since 10/11/2007

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 01:10:11  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send King Warrior a Private Message
Carsonova proslost, da je izasla u serijalu Zagor ostala bi neprimjecena i sigurno nebi spadala u top 50.
Mogu razumijeti da je u Tex serijalu to najbolja epizoda.
Smijesno pitanje, Zimska Zmija je totalno druga liga u odnosu na Carsonovu proslost, iako po meni ZZ nije mi mozda ni u top 15 Zagora, ali dovoljno dobra u poredjenju sa ovom Texovom epizodom.
Go to Top of Page

zlatan bihac
Advanced Member



Bosnia and Herzegovina
7718 Posts

Member since 24/03/2009

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 01:45:28  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send zlatan bihac a Yahoo! Message  Send zlatan bihac a Private Message
zimska zmija,za nijansu.
Go to Top of Page

Windwalker
Advanced Member



Croatia
4530 Posts

Member since 08/03/2008

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 01:49:30  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Windwalker a Private Message
I ja cu reci Zimska Zmija.

Ali ne zato jer mi je Zagor draži, nego zato jer mi Carsonova prošlost nije najbolji Tex. Uz toliki hype, nije me pretjerano oduševio dok sam citao. Iako je jako dobar.
No Zimska Zmija je bolja.
Go to Top of Page

Spookey
Starting Member



Bosnia and Herzegovina
99 Posts

Member since 20/06/2007

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 02:18:09  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Spookey a Private Message
Zimska zmija....
Go to Top of Page

tiberije
Average Member



USA
789 Posts

Member since 08/06/2007

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 03:28:25  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send tiberije a Private Message
Druze Zorane pa nije valjda da mislis da Karsonova proslost moze da pridje genijalnosti najbolje epizode Zagora u izvodjenu maestralnog Nollite.:):)
Trazim ritam u koraku, usporavim ti hod
Go to Top of Page

mars1
New Member

207 Posts

Member since 07/12/2007

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 07:52:23  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send mars1 a Private Message
Carsonova proslost
Go to Top of Page

Bardho
Senior Member

1943 Posts

Member since 10/04/2003

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 07:58:56  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Bardho a Private Message

Carsonova prošlost je za Zimsku Zmiju remek-djelo.
Go to Top of Page

Bruce Springsteen
Advanced Member



5545 Posts

Member since 28/10/2008

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 08:57:38  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Bruce Springsteen a Private Message
quote:
Originally posted by tiberije

Druze Zorane pa nije valjda da mislis da Karsonova proslost moze da pridje genijalnosti najbolje epizode Zagora u izvodjenu maestralnog Nollite.:):)


Svakako da ne Ali vecina vatrenih Tex-ovaca, a i onih koji to nisu tvrde da je Carsonova prošlost naj pirca Texa A kako je za vecinu vatrenih Zagor-ovaca "Zimska Zmija" druga ili cak naj prirca Zagora, i na osnovu realnosti jedne i druge price i tematike westerna i Divljeg zapada, bilo mi je logicno da se uporede ove dve price ova dva junaka
Go to Top of Page

cronos six
Advanced Member



Serbia
7916 Posts

Member since 09/09/2008

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 09:06:56  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send cronos six a Private Message
1:1
Go to Top of Page

teller
Advanced Member



Slovenia
18878 Posts

Member since 02/06/2008

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 09:11:04  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send teller an AOL message  Send teller an ICQ Message  Send teller a Yahoo! Message
Zimska zmija ali tesno,najviše zbog nostalgije i Ferrija...sory Tex i Marchelo.
CITAJTE TELLERA,... DA BI POSTALI BOLJI LJUDI!
STRIP JUNAK KOJI UCI POŠTENJU I PRAVDI!
Go to Top of Page

1Euro
Advanced Member



12493 Posts

Member since 17/07/2008

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 09:58:55  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send 1Euro a Private Message
z i m s k a z m i j a
Go to Top of Page

alba
Starting Member

2 Posts

Member since 03/08/2009

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 10:45:13  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send alba a Private Message
Carsonova prošlost bez ikakve dvojbe

Mene osobno je zimska zmija strašno razocarala, reklo bi se "nit smrdi nit miriše" ok epizoda ali ništa posebno dok me carsonova prošlost oduševila, jednostavno ostavila bez daha, predobro.
Go to Top of Page

gregorbikupil
Junior Member

Slovenia
428 Posts

Member since 13/03/2008

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 10:46:27  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send gregorbikupil a Private Message
Teks.
Iako je Zimska zmija sjajna prica. Naslovni junak je još posebno sjajan, jedan od najboljih karaktera u citavom serijalu.

Ali, tu je prevagala nostalgija, što puše iz Karsonove mladosti...

Ovo ce stvarno na penale.
Avatar mi je super... malo nihilisticki... a i sporo se nalaže... evo, sad ce...
Edited by - gregorbikupil on 04/09/2009 10:53:55
Go to Top of Page

dino1984
Average Member



Austria
530 Posts

Member since 31/05/2007

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 11:24:52  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send dino1984 a Private Message
Carsonova proslost!!!!!!1
Good night white pride!!
Go to Top of Page

srdjandj
Advanced Member



Serbia
22426 Posts

Member since 02/05/2005

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 12:08:01  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send srdjandj a Private Message
Karsonova prošlost!
Iz Vršca stiže glas, u vinu leži spas, ko vino ne pije, taj nek se ubije!!!
Go to Top of Page

ponki
Advanced Member



Bosnia and Herzegovina
3112 Posts

Member since 20/09/2008

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 12:12:48  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send ponki a Private Message
Zimska zmija...
Be yourself; everyone else is already taken.
Go to Top of Page

jasa
Advanced Member



Bosnia and Herzegovina
3490 Posts

Member since 26/08/2005

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 12:16:44  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send jasa an ICQ Message  Send jasa a Private Message
Ma Karson odnosi pobjedu :D
Go to Top of Page

okiboki
Advanced Member



Serbia
10835 Posts

Member since 23/11/2008

Posted - 04/09/2009 : 14:06:34  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send okiboki a Private Message
Ovde bolje da si pitao koga vise volite Zagora ili Texa.Texa ne citam,tako da Zimska zmija.
Ni živih se nisam boja, dok su bili za užasa, a nekmoli mrtvih pasa.
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 5 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Next Page
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Topic Locked
Jump To:
forum.stripovi.com © 2000-2002 Snitz Communications Go To Top Of Page
This page was generated in 0.17 seconds. Snitz Forums 2000