forum.stripovi.com
forum.stripovi.com
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Active Polls | Aukcije | Private Messages | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
 Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Stripovi
 Stripovi
 Ocjenite serijal: Alan Ford GOTOVO		  New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 2

alanford
Senior Member



Bosnia and Herzegovina
1169 Posts

Member since 31/03/2009

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 11:10:21  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send alanford a Yahoo! Message  Send alanford a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Poll Question:

Zadni poll o kvalitetu strip serijala Alan Ford je bio u Septembru 2009. godine kada je imao srednju ocjenu 3,94(http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=35196). Na tom glasanju 9% forumasa je dalo najnizu ocjenu bez ikakvog logicnog obrazlozenja i molio bih sve clanove koji ce ovog puta glasati da daju sto objektivniju ocjenu da bi imali jednu konacnu ocjenu tog strip serijala od strane portala stripovi.com.
Otada smo dobili veliki broj novih clanova i mnostvo novih izdanja pogotovo u Klasik i Extra seriji i zato mislim da je pravo vrijeme za novo glasanje.

Srednja ocjena : 3.85

Sto znaci da je pala sa 3.94. Sta vi mislite o konacnoj ocjeni?

Choices:
5
4
3
2
1

Who Can Vote? Only Members can vote. You need to register or be logged in to vote.
Edited by - alanford on 04/03/2011 18:49:07

paro
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8619 Posts

Member since 30/03/2005

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 11:29:37  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit paro's Homepage  Send paro a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Kolko ja znam klasik superklasik, i ne znam kakv sve ne klasik je jednostavno reprint starih epizoda. E sad, pošto to ne kupujem, ne znam koliko je kvalitetan print, uvez itd. Borgisov print je užasan na užasnom papiru s još užasnijim uvezom. S druge strane, ako misliš da treba ocjenit priču stripa onda joj dajem komad. Popravnog nema. Em se priča pretvorila u noćnu moru, em klinci ne mogu ništa naučit iz tog stripa. Amen!
There he goes. One of God's own prototypes. A high-powered mutant of some kind never even considered for mass production. Too weird to live, and too rare to die.
Go to Top of Page

Zlotvor
Advanced Member



7094 Posts

Member since 03/02/2010

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 12:14:26  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Zlotvor a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Bez puno premišljanja: 5!
Mislim da tu ne bi uopće trebalo bit dvojbe, budući da se radi o kultnom stripu.
Ja ga osobno ne skupljam, niti čitam redovito al kad mi koji padne pod ruku pročitam ga s guštom.
Trljam ruke.
Go to Top of Page

skuby
Average Member



Croatia
764 Posts

Member since 06/02/2011

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 12:41:29  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send skuby a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Ja sam Alan Forda ocijenio s čistom 5.
Strip mi je najbolji od svih koje čitam iako su nove epizode pomalo dosadne.
Strip je humorističan i ima jako dobro fore.
Sve pohvale Magnusu i Bunkeru :)
Go to Top of Page

Ultras
Advanced Member



Serbia
10061 Posts

Member since 17/10/2008

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 13:02:28  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit Ultras's Homepage  Send Ultras a Private Message  Reply with Quote



5





Šta reći o Alan Fordu...

Samo uzeti strip u ruke i uživati


Svet stripa - portal - instagram - blog - facebook - twitter
Go to Top of Page

sawitch
Advanced Member



Serbia
40975 Posts

Member since 17/11/2007

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 13:22:38  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send sawitch a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Petica.. Imam ceo klasik HC...
Patricia hic mea totus mundus est
Go to Top of Page

morrison
Advanced Member



Serbia
5142 Posts

Member since 29/01/2008

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 13:40:45  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send morrison a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Vr. dobar 4, na staklenim nogama.
Pre izvesnog vremena sam batalio u potpunosti Alana. 'Svetove' epizode su uspele da mi ogade ceo serijal. Sam koncept stripa je genijalan, medjutim previse je katastrofalnih epizoda.
There ain't no grave gonna hold my body down.
Go to Top of Page

duck
Junior Member

409 Posts

Member since 26/01/2007

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 13:52:29  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send duck a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Cijeli serijal ne moze vise od 3.
Prvih 100, pa cak i do broja 300 5+,
medjutim poslednjih 100 maximalno 2+,
a od pojave Minuette ne moze niti 2.To je jednostavno necitljivo,a humora ni u tragovima.
Go to Top of Page

supermark
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
29651 Posts

Member since 06/02/2007

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 14:07:40  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit supermark's Homepage  Send supermark a Private Message  Reply with Quote
ovaj legendarni serijal ima toliko oscilacija u kvaliteti da ga je praktički nemoguće ocijeniti sa jednom jedinstvenom ocjenom
Go to Top of Page

paro
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8619 Posts

Member since 30/03/2005

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 14:13:16  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit paro's Homepage  Send paro a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by supermark

ovaj legendarni serijal ima toliko oscilacija u kvaliteti da ga je praktički nemoguće ocijeniti sa jednom jedinstvenom ocjenom


potpuno se slažem, odlično verbalizirano , a ja sam zaista dao ocjenu 1, jer po meni je jedino logično da se ocjenjuju današnje epizode AF-a, a ne 1969.-1975. il šta ti ja znam.
There he goes. One of God's own prototypes. A high-powered mutant of some kind never even considered for mass production. Too weird to live, and too rare to die.
Go to Top of Page

Zagor12
Advanced Member



Croatia
6763 Posts

Member since 23/08/2010

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 14:18:27  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit Zagor12's Homepage  Send Zagor12 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
3
Jer ga je Bunker s godinama potpuno uništio.
Z12 je sada Golub, ali sajt je ostao isti:
http://superheroji.com.hr/ - Najnovije iz svijeta superheroja
Go to Top of Page

marcho
New Member



Croatia
270 Posts

Member since 23/04/2008

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 15:01:24  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send marcho a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Eto mu jedna čista dvojka, kao neki prosjek...
Edited by - marcho on 27/02/2011 15:01:46
Go to Top of Page

Rico
Advanced Member



Croatia
3955 Posts

Member since 12/10/2004

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 15:19:35  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit Rico's Homepage  Send Rico a Private Message  Reply with Quote
5
https://www.instagram.com/ricomambo_tees/ https://www.facebook.com/brankoricovdesign
Go to Top of Page

velka031
Advanced Member



Croatia
17094 Posts

Member since 18/03/2010

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 17:21:24  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send velka031 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Čista 4... Jako puno novijih loših epizoda je pokvarilo dojam, inače je to strip koji je kategorija za sebe, nikad mi ne može dosaditi čitati prvih 100 epizoda, legendarno...
Go to Top of Page

Darth Ivan
Advanced Member



Croatia
7978 Posts

Member since 21/03/2010

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 17:28:19  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Darth Ivan a Private Message  Reply with Quote
ocjena u biti ovisi o tome koji period uspoređuješ i gledaš.
prvih cca 180 epizoda (magnus i piffarerio period) bi mogao ocijenit više-manje ocjenom 5, ali nakon toga slijedi silazna putanja kaj se tiče kvalitete stripa. ima nakon toga još dobrih epizoda, kao što je dobro poznat serijal o smrti broja 1 i mangia, ali one nisu ništa drugo nego bunkerovi zadnji trzaji, ajmo to tako nazvat. ove današnje "minuette" epizode (od 2005. g. do danas) su dotaknule samo dno, ništa više...ukoliko bi gledali ovaj strip u cjelini, ja bi ga ocijenio konačnom ocjenom 3.
"Nothing lasts forever."
Edited by - Darth Ivan on 27/02/2011 17:31:51
Go to Top of Page

ninel
Senior Member



Serbia
1591 Posts

Member since 16/11/2004

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 17:36:03  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send ninel a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Alan Ford je za mene samo od broja 1 do broja 75 i to je dakako čista petica! Ostalo ne vredi ni pola lule duvana.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SSRVtlTwFs8&feature=related
Go to Top of Page

Darth Ivan
Advanced Member



Croatia
7978 Posts

Member since 21/03/2010

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 17:36:59  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Darth Ivan a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by ninel

Alan Ford je za mene samo od broja 1 do broja 75 i to je dakako čista petica! Ostalo ne vredi ni pola lule duvana.


nemoj pretjerivat
"Nothing lasts forever."
Go to Top of Page

paro
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8619 Posts

Member since 30/03/2005

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 17:45:29  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit paro's Homepage  Send paro a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Darth Ivan

quote:
Originally posted by ninel

Alan Ford je za mene samo od broja 1 do broja 75 i to je dakako čista petica! Ostalo ne vredi ni pola lule duvana.


nemoj pretjerivat


Slažem se s ninelom, piffa je totalna truba
There he goes. One of God's own prototypes. A high-powered mutant of some kind never even considered for mass production. Too weird to live, and too rare to die.
Go to Top of Page

Darth Ivan
Advanced Member



Croatia
7978 Posts

Member since 21/03/2010

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 17:48:58  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Darth Ivan a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by paro


Slažem se s ninelom, piffa je totalna truba


a della monica, staff di if, warco, nizzoli i ostala ekipa?
"Nothing lasts forever."
Go to Top of Page

Opti
stripovi.com suradnik



Vatican City
4533 Posts

Member since 06/07/2009

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 18:00:21  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Opti a Private Message  Reply with Quote
1
Rindfleischetikettierungsüberwachungsaufgabenübert ragungsgesetz!!
Go to Top of Page

Mairosu
Advanced Member



6689 Posts

Member since 03/07/2008

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 18:14:47  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Mairosu a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Alan Ford prvih 100tinak epizoda je 5+, to je nezaboravni klasik koji se integrisao u kulturu i nacin zivota u ex-SFRJ.

Posle toga, progresivno pada kvalitet. Negde narednih 100tinak brojeva je OK, pogotovo story arc o navodnoj smrti broja 1. Posle toga je vec kupovina po inerciji, pizdarija sa Mangiom, dupla izdaja Cezara itd, strip gubi osnovnu funkciju, sve manje je sprdnja, sve vise su oni kao "ozbiljni" tajni agenti, i to postaje bleda senka onoga sto nekad bese. Originalna vizija se potpuno izgubila, satiricni prizvuk je nestao...

Kada neko kaze "alan ford", naravno da se pamti prvih 100. Ne znam ko moze identifikovati grupu TNT sa Mangiom, Antenmanom ili tome sl. Tako da, na taj utisak, ocena 5+. Ovako ukupno, 4-, i to samo zato sto prve epizode DALEKO nadjebavaju sve ostalo i bacaju cak i mediokritete u zasenak (inace realno 2+, koliko je sranja proslo pod AF firmom...).
Ko igra za raju, i zanemaruje taktiku, zavrsit ce karijeru u nizerazrednom Vratniku.

Kakav ti je kupus, takva ti je sarma -- otac Tadej
Go to Top of Page

paro
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8619 Posts

Member since 30/03/2005

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 18:26:25  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit paro's Homepage  Send paro a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Darth Ivan

quote:
Originally posted by paro


Slažem se s ninelom, piffa je totalna truba


a della monica, staff di if, warco, nizzoli i ostala ekipa?


staff di if je crtač
There he goes. One of God's own prototypes. A high-powered mutant of some kind never even considered for mass production. Too weird to live, and too rare to die.
Go to Top of Page

docA
Advanced Member



8104 Posts

Member since 14/09/2008

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 18:36:21  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Reply with Quote
Go to Top of Page

cronos six
Advanced Member



Serbia
7962 Posts

Member since 09/09/2008

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 18:54:26  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send cronos six a Private Message  Reply with Quote
kupujem i clasic i extra(imam sve).ocena 5 vredi samo za prva 75 magnusova broja.sve posle toga ne zasluzuje vecu ocenu od trojke,pa cak i dvojke sto se tice vestice minuet!
u kompletu,prosecna ocena 3.
Juznjak!
Tex Willer.
Go to Top of Page

swamp thing
Advanced Member



Bosnia and Herzegovina
4078 Posts

Member since 05/08/2009

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 19:59:13  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send swamp thing a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Mislim da nisam citao nista poslije broja 100, i za taj period mu dajem 4. Humor je definitivno zastitni znak serijala.
Go to Top of Page

Shiva314
Junior Member



Croatia
336 Posts

Member since 16/07/2004

Posted - 27/02/2011 : 20:03:21  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Shiva314 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
HC? Ih, šminkeru!
Ali razumijem, serijal za 5 pa ga i treba sačuvat u dobrom pakovanju.
quote:
Originally posted by sawitch

Petica.. Imam ceo klasik HC...
I am the Lord of all Evil...but you can call me Cookie
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 2 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Next Page
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Jump To:
forum.stripovi.com © 2000-2002 Snitz Communications Go To Top Of Page
This page was generated in 0.2 seconds. Snitz Forums 2000