forum.stripovi.com
forum.stripovi.com
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Active Polls | Aukcije | Private Messages | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
 Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Stripovi
 Bonelli
 Capone ili Sclavi		  New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 4

solar
Moderator



Croatia
21432 Posts

Member since 16/03/2004

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 12:43:30  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send solar a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Poll Question:
Nakon "dvoboja" Bosellija i Burattinija, vrijeme je za još jedan okršaj Zagorovih scenarista.

Pitanje:
Koji od ova dva Zagorova scenarista vama osobno najviše odgovara, odnosno čije priče radije čitate?


Pet najbolje ocijenjenih priča ovog autorskog dvojca po mišljenju fanova na ovom sajtu...

Capone:
1. Hiljadu lica straha 92%
2. Hagotova moć 92%
3. Kraljevstvo straha 89%
4. Marinci 82%
5. Poplava u Darkvudu 76%


Sclavi:
1. Divovi dobra i zla 91%
2. Demonska maska 87%
3. Prokleto blago 85%
4. Vuk samotnjak 84%
5. Ludi Hakaram 82%

Choices:
Capone
Sclavi

Who Can Vote? Only Members can vote. You need to register or be logged in to vote.
Edited by - solar on 09/08/2015 19:06:09

PijaniPatak
stripovi.com suradnik



Germany
10035 Posts

Member since 20/02/2010

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 12:51:23  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send PijaniPatak a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Opet bez da trepnem: Capone

Sclaviju je trebalo brdo naivluka da bi došao do "Divova...". Manje naivna priča bi bio sam "Vuk Samotnjak". "Demonska Maska" je postigla takav-kakav uspeh samo zbog harizmatičnosti naslovnog lika i Ferrijevog crteža. Scenario inače uopšte ne pije vode, 92% je preterano visoka procena.

A Capone je pukao snažno odmah na početku: Hagot, Hiljadu lica straha, Dijablar... Mislim da tu nema mnogo priče
DNEVNIK CITANJA:
Etika junaštva i deklišeizirani koreni u “Zagor prica...”
Go to Top of Page

markotamara
Senior Member



Croatia
2783 Posts

Member since 26/05/2013

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 13:09:03  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send markotamara a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Da sam glas Sclaviu ali da postoji glasanje oba su mi jednako odlicna
GALLIENO FERRI
Go to Top of Page

PijaniPatak
stripovi.com suradnik



Germany
10035 Posts

Member since 20/02/2010

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 13:12:30  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send PijaniPatak a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Vidim da Sclavi već vodi na osnovu samo jedne do dve priče...očekivalo se
DNEVNIK CITANJA:
Etika junaštva i deklišeizirani koreni u “Zagor prica...”
Go to Top of Page

King Warrior
stripovi.com suradnik



22315 Posts

Member since 10/11/2007

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 13:12:49  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send King Warrior a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Iako je Capone zaista odlican autor, Sclavija smatram najboljim scenaristom koji je ikada krocio nogom u SBE.
Ne samo kada je Zagor u pitanju, kod Dylana je od trecerazrednih horror filmova bio u stanju da napravi odlicne price.
Go to Top of Page

Tutta
Advanced Member



Germany
32401 Posts

Member since 19/02/2010

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 13:21:01  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Tutta a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Capone
+IN HOC SIGNO VINCES+
Go to Top of Page

Timber Bil
Senior Member

1068 Posts

Member since 02/10/2013

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 13:26:52  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Timber Bil a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Sclavija ne cenim na Dilanu previše, a opet na Zagoru je dao mnogo, najveći Bonelli strip svih vremena-Divove, jako drage Horde zla, Hakarama...
Go to Top of Page

Bruce Springsteen
Advanced Member



5545 Posts

Member since 28/10/2008

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 13:27:53  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Bruce Springsteen a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Capone
Go to Top of Page

DzekDenijels
Senior Member



Serbia
2473 Posts

Member since 26/07/2009

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 13:30:18  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit DzekDenijels's Homepage  Send DzekDenijels a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Sclavi...
Carpe diem
Go to Top of Page

Opti
stripovi.com suradnik



Vatican City
4533 Posts

Member since 06/07/2009

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 13:37:36  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Opti a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Jedva da sam čitao išta od Caponea međutim Marinci su mi super, ali ne mogu na osnovu samo jedne priče glasati.

Sclavi je karakterno zanimljiv tip i napisao je nebrojene odlične Bonelli priče, npr. Prokleto blago (potcijenjena, odlična epizoda), ili najbolji Bonelli strip svih vremena, Anangu u MN-u, ali je zato zaslužan i za najveća sranja i zlodjela ikad počinjena nad 9. umjetnošću (hrpa DD-ova, kao recimo Zlo, Tajanstveni otok i sl.).
Rindfleischetikettierungsüberwachungsaufgabenübert ragungsgesetz!!
Go to Top of Page

mpavin
Advanced Member



Niue
7819 Posts

Member since 02/09/2005

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 13:48:43  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send mpavin a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Capone
Go to Top of Page

solar
Moderator



Croatia
21432 Posts

Member since 16/03/2004

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 13:58:24  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send solar a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Da je pitanje "tko je od njih dvojice, općenito govoreći, bolji scenarist?", glasovao bi za Sclavija. Ovdje nije o tome riječ, gledamo njihove radove na Zagoru.
Sclavi se previše udaljio od Nolitte, što je još i više naglašeno jer je pisao scenarije odmah poslije njegovog odlaska. Naravno to ne znači da Sclavi nema odličnih priča, samo one za moj ukus nisu dovoljno bliske "originalu".
Capone, premda kao i Sclavi naginje "mračnjaštvu", ipak ima više nolittanskog u sebi i njegov Zagor mi je draži.
Edited by - solar on 12/04/2014 14:00:30
Go to Top of Page

stinky
stripovi.com suradnik

Croatia
13122 Posts

Member since 29/12/2001

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 14:00:41  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit stinky's Homepage  Send stinky a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Općenito je Sclavi bolji, na DD-u se upisao u vječnost.
A na Zagoru, ha podjednako, možda je Capone nešto bolji.
Go to Top of Page

Koresh
stripovi.com suradnik



2992 Posts

Member since 18/09/2004

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 14:36:42  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Koresh a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Capone zbog Opsade tvrđave Erie i Lova na vuka
Go to Top of Page

solar
Moderator



Croatia
21432 Posts

Member since 16/03/2004

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 14:44:44  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send solar a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by PijaniPatak

Vidim da Sclavi već vodi na osnovu samo jedne do dve priče...očekivalo se

Things change...
Edited by - solar on 12/04/2014 14:46:58
Go to Top of Page

roby05
Advanced Member



Croatia
3016 Posts

Member since 26/07/2013

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 14:45:58  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send roby05 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Capone,bez dileme.
Evala ti dalmatinski puce,pozdrav tebi s Poljuda Hajduce,nasem moru,galebu i skoju,Boze cuvaj Dalmaciju moju.
Go to Top of Page

PijaniPatak
stripovi.com suradnik



Germany
10035 Posts

Member since 20/02/2010

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 14:55:23  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send PijaniPatak a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by solar

quote:
Originally posted by PijaniPatak

Vidim da Sclavi već vodi na osnovu samo jedne do dve priče...očekivalo se

Things change...


Dakle, za zdrav razum gomile ima nade

(a, jesam proklet, čoveče!!!)
DNEVNIK CITANJA:
Etika junaštva i deklišeizirani koreni u “Zagor prica...”
Go to Top of Page

going going
Advanced Member



Serbia
11867 Posts

Member since 24/04/2012

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 15:06:37  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send going going a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Bez razmisljanja Capone! Covek je legenda! Napisao je Sveti breg, epizodu zbog koje sam se potpuno zaljubio u Zagora i koja me je navukla da nabavim sve epizode! Pored toga, jos je napisao Mracna predskazanja, Marince...

Sclavijeve prve epizode na Zagoru su dosta detinjaste, najbolje price su mu samo Divovi dobra i zla i Prokleto blago i to je to. Ovo ostalo nije nista posebno.
Go to Top of Page

anto
Advanced Member



Serbia
21111 Posts

Member since 29/06/2008

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 15:14:55  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send anto a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Kapone
Dajte nam Ralph Azhama;može i mekokoricen (ali u boji obavezno)!
Go to Top of Page

tinton
stripovi.com suradnik

United Kingdom
19694 Posts

Member since 23/10/2011

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 15:38:29  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send tinton a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Capone naravno. Sclavi je bez veze.
Dajte nam Banija Libre;može i mekokoricen (ali u boji obavezno)!
Go to Top of Page

Brdar
Senior Member

Bosnia and Herzegovina
2770 Posts

Member since 22/10/2003

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 16:08:27  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Brdar a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Nisam glasao, meni su oba podjednako dobri.
Edited by - Brdar on 12/04/2014 16:08:46
Go to Top of Page

Johnny Difool
Advanced Member



Croatia
13988 Posts

Member since 21/02/2010

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 16:45:15  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Johnny Difool a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Sclavi apsolutno.

Ne samo zbog Divova..., nego i zbog toga što su mi njegove priče (bile) bitnije, što imaju veću mitotvornu vrijednost i funkcionalnost, što je bolje implementirao stravu i fantastiku, a dijelom i zbog nostalgije, jer sam ga čitao u vrijeme kad mi je Zagor bio važniji i zanimljiviji.
Ja necu imati s kim ostati mlad ako svi ostarite,
i ta ce mi mladost teško pasti...
Go to Top of Page

ike666
Average Member



709 Posts

Member since 01/11/2012

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 17:20:57  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send ike666 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Volim obojicu i obojica imaju odlične priče, ali kada moram birati onda je to ipak Sclavi, jer njegove se pročitaju jednom, a pamte čitav život
Rendal Mutant, Tkac, Jednooki Džek, Vatreno oko...
Go to Top of Page

DODSFERD
Advanced Member



Pitcairn Island
29953 Posts

Member since 14/03/2014

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 18:50:25  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send DODSFERD a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Ne sjećam se niti jedne Caponeove priče a s druge strane Sclavi je imao od fantastičnih do vrlo loših epizoda tako da je teško reći...
Sinaitakala Tu'imatamoana 'i Fanakavakilangi Fakafanua
Go to Top of Page

sergej773
Senior Member



Cuba
1922 Posts

Member since 03/06/2012

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 19:01:45  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send sergej773 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Bez dileme, Sclavi.
Go to Top of Page

Leonid
Senior Member



Croatia
2448 Posts

Member since 24/12/2010

Posted - 12/04/2014 : 19:59:35  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Leonid a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Capone
"Liston even smells like a bear. I'm gonna give him to the local zoo after I whup him"
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 4 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Next Page
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Jump To:
forum.stripovi.com © 2000-2002 Snitz Communications Go To Top Of Page
This page was generated in 0.18 seconds. Snitz Forums 2000