forum.stripovi.com
forum.stripovi.com
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Active Polls | Aukcije | Private Messages | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
 Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Stripovi
 Stripovi
 IZBOR ZA RECENZIJU MESECA		  New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Previous Page | Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 176

Tutta
Advanced Member



Germany
32771 Posts

Member since 19/02/2010

Posted - 16/01/2021 : 22:02:43  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Tutta a Private Message  Reply with Quote
4 boda - TEX WILLER: Beli Vrač by tex2

2 boda - ZAGOR: Hellingenova sudbina by igor 12

1 bod - STRIP ALBUM: Zatamnjenje by going going
+IN HOC SIGNO VINCES+
Go to Top of Page

Altairfan
Junior Member



476 Posts

Member since 12/12/2019

Posted - 21/01/2021 : 17:16:40  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Altairfan a Private Message  Reply with Quote
4 boda - STRIP ALBUM: Zatamnjenje by going going

2 boda - ZAGOR: Hellingenova sudbina by igor 12

1 bod - TEX WILLER: Beli Vrač by tex2
Go to Top of Page

DinkoJ
New Member



248 Posts

Member since 09/11/2018

Posted - 22/01/2021 : 12:25:56  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send DinkoJ a Private Message  Reply with Quote
4 boda- Strip album:Zatamnjenje
2 boda- Zagor: Hellingenova sudbina
1 bod - ALAN FORD: Nestao je BuBu by Kila Banana
Go to Top of Page

going going
Advanced Member



Serbia
12106 Posts

Member since 24/04/2012

Posted - 31/01/2021 : 03:20:20  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send going going a Private Message  Reply with Quote
4 boda Tjeskoba by Spock
2 boda Helingenova sudbina by Igor12
1 bod MISTER NO: Gospodarica tajne by Koresh
Go to Top of Page

Ernie Pike
Senior Member



Croatia
2959 Posts

Member since 06/03/2012

Posted - 31/01/2021 : 21:43:01  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Ernie Pike a Private Message  Reply with Quote
STRIP ALBUM: Zatamnjenje by going going - 4 boda
ZAGOR: Hellingenova sudbina by igor 12 - 2 boda
BATMAN: Three Jokers by Paka01 - 1 bod
Go to Top of Page

Jerry Krause
stripovi.com suradnik



Western Samoa
7473 Posts

Member since 12/11/2009

Posted - 01/02/2021 : 12:52:17  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Jerry Krause a Private Message  Reply with Quote
POBJEDNIK 12. MJESECA JE:






ZATAMNJENJE by going going






Link za pobjedničku recku:

https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/strip-album-album-klo-sp-30-zatamnjenje/2531/

Uh, koja je ovo brutalna pobjeda bila. Nevjerojatnih 39 Goingovih bodova bilo je i više nego dovoljno za uvjerljivu pobjedu. Čestitke na odličnoj recenziji koja će zahvaljujući pobjedi biti u konkurenciji za skorašnji izbor recenzije godine. I naravno, zaslužena nagrada u obliku Fibrine knjige.

Poredak za 12. mjesec:

1. Zatamnjenje by going going - 39 bodova
2. Hellingenova sudbina by igor 12 - 22 boda
3. Beli vrač by tex2 - 6 bodova
4. Three Jokers by Paka01 - 4 boda
4. Tjeskoba by Spock - 4 boda
4. My Friend Dahmer by Paka01 - 4 boda
7. Gospodarica tajne by Koresh - 3 boda
8. Okrutni Kid by Hercule Poirot - 1 bod
8. Nestao je BuBu by Kila Banana - 1 bod
Go to Top of Page

koze123
Average Member



967 Posts

Member since 05/11/2018

Posted - 01/02/2021 : 22:31:35  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send koze123 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Bravo Goinže, upisa se i ti u Hall of Fame! Zasluženo sasvim, jako dobra recenzija!
Go to Top of Page

ReemCP
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
14465 Posts

Member since 03/01/2018

Posted - 01/02/2021 : 23:34:10  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send ReemCP a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Čestitke Going Going na zasluženo osvojenoj nagradi Naš Paka je lijepo zaključio prethodnu godinu, a tvoja nije mogla bolje započeti Nadam se da ćeš nam u budućnosti pružiti još lijepih i zanimljivih tekstova, samo naprijed!
Never leave it in the hands of the judges
Go to Top of Page

Paka01
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
11453 Posts

Member since 14/02/2009

Posted - 01/02/2021 : 23:38:41  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Paka01 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Čestitam!
Would a new flood please finally come? A real rain and an assortment of plagues
And when all is said and done, even the Devil won't care enough to spit in the mud

https://www.last.fm/user/Pakaa
Go to Top of Page

paro
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8618 Posts

Member since 30/03/2005

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 00:39:47  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit paro's Homepage  Send paro a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Čestitke goinže!

A sad valjda konačno slijede izbori za recku i recenzenta godine. Mislim da već znam kamo će ić moji glasovi, al ću preletit još jednom sve mjesečne pobjednike za svaki slučaj.
There he goes. One of God's own prototypes. A high-powered mutant of some kind never even considered for mass production. Too weird to live, and too rare to die.
Go to Top of Page

going going
Advanced Member



Serbia
12106 Posts

Member since 24/04/2012

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 00:45:57  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send going going a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Hvala mnogo momci! Znace pohvale od velikih recezentskih imena ovog sajta! Hvala i svima koji su glasali! Bice jos recenzija ubuduce naravno, ali pitanje kad ce neki strip ovako da me inspirise kao Zatamnjenje.
Edited by - going going on 02/02/2021 00:46:22
Go to Top of Page

Spock
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8009 Posts

Member since 26/12/2006

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 07:28:35  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Spock a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Čestitke going going!
Kamo god da kreneš, uvijek si tu.
Go to Top of Page

Hercule Poirot
stripovi.com suradnik



14459 Posts

Member since 28/11/2017

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 07:35:46  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Hercule Poirot a Private Message  Reply with Quote
@Going going, čestitke!
Go to Top of Page

tex2
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
32960 Posts

Member since 17/09/2006

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 08:16:33  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send tex2 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Čestitam!
"Od svakog treba tražiti samo ono što on može dati."
"The puck is in! The home team wins!", the good ol' hockey game
Go to Top of Page

Jerry Krause
stripovi.com suradnik



Western Samoa
7473 Posts

Member since 12/11/2009

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 09:46:15  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Jerry Krause a Private Message  Reply with Quote
IZBOR ZA NAJBOLJU RECENZIJU 1. MJESECA (siječanj/januar) (2021. god.)



VELIKI MRTVAC: Veliki Mrtvac by koze123
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/velika-smrt-kolorka-132-veliki-mrtvac/2569/

KOMANDANT MARK: Osujećena zavjera by Hercule Poirot
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-zs-799-osujecena-zavjera/2568/

ZAGOR: Smirnoffova osveta by igor 12
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/zagor-zg-lu-308-smirnoffova-osveta/2567/

TEX WILLER: Tročlana banda by tex2
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/tex-willer-tx-vec-54-55-troclana-banda/2566/

TEX WILLER: Dva gerilca by igor 12
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/tex-willer-tx-lib-57-dva-gerilca/2565/

MAXMAGNUS: Jezero čuda by GitaristRoko
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/maxmagnus-mxm-sa-3-jezero-cuda/2564/

KOMANDANT MARK: Pljačkaši by Hercule Poirot
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-zs-738-pljackasi/2563/

MISTER NO: Prvak by Koresh
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/mister-no-mn-sa-23-prvak/2561/

TEX WILLER: Krater strave by igor 12
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/tex-willer-tx-zs-301-krater-strave/2556/

KOMANDANT MARK: Put osvete by Hercule Poirot
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-lu-24-put-osvete/2555/

ZAGOR: Šumske priče by igor 12
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/zagor-zg-mx-37-sumske-price/2554/

MARTIN MYSTERE: Buđenje Tiamat by DeeCay
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/martin-mystere-mm-vec-54-budenje-tiamat/2553/

TEX WILLER: Muddy Creek by tex2
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/tex-willer-tx-lu-151-152-muddy-creek/2552/

KOMANDANT MARK: Bura by Hercule Poirot
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-zs-927-bura/2551/

NICK RAIDER: Umorstvo u Central Parku by ReemCP
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/nick-raider-nr-lib-2b-umorstvo-u-central-parku/2550/

RIĐOBRADI: Sablasni brod by Hercule Poirot
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/ridobradi-cb-lib-6-7-sablasni-brod/2549/


REZIME:

Možemo reći da na početku godine Tex i Mark čvrsto drže uzde i njihove recenzije većinom dominiraju na sajtu. Pozdravljamo novu mladu spisateljsku nadu. GItaristRoko je debitirao s Maxmagnisovom recenzijom dok se ostali prekaljeni recenzenti većinom drže svojih provjerenih junaka. Izuzetak je kozeova recenzija jednog poznatog francuskog integrala.

quote:
Originally posted by Spock



Po serijalima bi to bilo:
Tex - 4
Zagor - 2
Martin Mystére - 1
Nick Raider - 1
Mister No - 1
+
Komandant Mark - 4
Maxmagnus - 1
Riđobradi - 1
Strip integrali (Veliki Mrtvac) - 1


Po recenzentima situacija je:
Hercule Poirot - 5 (Komandant Mark^4 + Riđobradi)
igor 12 - 4 (Tex^2 + Zagor^2)
tex2 - 2 (Tex^2)
DeeCay - 1 (Martin Mystére)
Koresh - 1 (Mister No)
ReemCP - 1 (Nick Raider)
koze123 - 1 (Veliki Mrtvac integral)
GitaristRoko - 1 (Maxmagnus)


Edited by - Jerry Krause on 02/02/2021 10:37:46
Go to Top of Page

Deers
Advanced Member



Croatia
9548 Posts

Member since 29/03/2004

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 09:52:24  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Deers a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Veliki mrtvac
Buđenje Tiamat
Šumske priče
"Trzaj mišica i nad prazninom sam."
Go to Top of Page

Paka01
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
11453 Posts

Member since 14/02/2009

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 10:45:10  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Paka01 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
1. Veliki mrtvac
2. Krater strave
3. Smirnoffova osveta
Would a new flood please finally come? A real rain and an assortment of plagues
And when all is said and done, even the Devil won't care enough to spit in the mud

https://www.last.fm/user/Pakaa
Go to Top of Page

Hercule Poirot
stripovi.com suradnik



14459 Posts

Member since 28/11/2017

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 11:37:10  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Hercule Poirot a Private Message  Reply with Quote
4- Umorstvo u Central Parku
2- Prvak
1- Tročlana banda
Go to Top of Page

paro
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8618 Posts

Member since 30/03/2005

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 12:06:08  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit paro's Homepage  Send paro a Private Message  Reply with Quote
4 boda- Veliki mrtvac
2 boda- Buđenje Tiamat
1 ubod- Jezero čuda
There he goes. One of God's own prototypes. A high-powered mutant of some kind never even considered for mass production. Too weird to live, and too rare to die.
Go to Top of Page

RadioClash
Senior Member



Virgin Islands (United Kingdom)
1670 Posts

Member since 20/11/2015

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 12:15:31  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send RadioClash a Private Message  Reply with Quote
4 boda - VELIKI MRTVAC: Veliki Mrtvac
2 boda - MAXMAGNUS: Jezero čuda
1 ubod - MARTIN MYSTERE: Buđenje Tiamat
"Gambare Gambare Senpai"
Go to Top of Page

Spock
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8009 Posts

Member since 26/12/2006

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 13:04:07  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Spock a Private Message  Reply with Quote
4 boda - RIĐOBRADI: Sablasni brod by Hercule Poirot (Ne mogu vjerovati da još nitko nije glasao za ovu recenziju!)
2 boda - NICK RAIDER: Umorstvo u Central Parku by ReemCP (Simpatično - po dobrom, starom, reem običaju!)
1 bod - MAXMAGNUS: Jezero čuda by GitaristRoko (Velika pohvala na premijernoj recenziji za trinaestogodišnjeg Roka! )
Kamo god da kreneš, uvijek si tu.
Edited by - Spock on 02/02/2021 13:08:59
Go to Top of Page

ReemCP
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
14465 Posts

Member since 03/01/2018

Posted - 02/02/2021 : 22:04:57  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send ReemCP a Private Message  Reply with Quote
4 boda - KOMANDANT MARK: Bura by Hercule Poirot
2 boda - ZAGOR: Smirnoffova osveta by igor 12
1 bod - RIĐOBRADI: Sablasni brod by Hercule Poirot
Never leave it in the hands of the judges
Go to Top of Page

going going
Advanced Member



Serbia
12106 Posts

Member since 24/04/2012

Posted - 03/02/2021 : 01:26:14  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send going going a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Spock

Čestitke going going!


Hvala Spock!

quote:
Originally posted by Hercule Poirot

@Going going, čestitke!


Hvala Hercule, legendo!

quote:
Originally posted by tex2

Čestitam!


Hvala tex2!

A sto se tice glasanja ovog meseca, meni je svakog meseca pretesko da se odlucim kako da dodelim bodove a jos zalije mi je sto moram da izostavim neke sjajne recezencije i recenzente. Ne znam da li je takav slucaj i sa ostalima, da li mozda da se uvede da se boduje svaka recenzija ili neki drugaciji vid glasanja, ne znam.

Ovog meseca bih glasao ovako:
4 boda Veliki Mrtvac by koze123
2 boda RIĐOBRADI: Sablasni brod by Hercule Poirot
1 bod MAXMAGNUS: Jezero čuda by GitaristRoko

Zao mi je sto sam morao da izostavim odlicnu recenziju kolege Koresha MISTER NO: Prvak i ReemCPovu recenziju za Nika. A i cak 4 odlicne recenzije Herculea i Igora 12 i jos 2 od tex2. I standardno kvalitetnog Dee Caya i novog Martija.
Go to Top of Page

Hercule Poirot
stripovi.com suradnik



14459 Posts

Member since 28/11/2017

Posted - 03/02/2021 : 07:45:17  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Hercule Poirot a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Going je u pravu. Previše je dobrih recenzija, a da bi se bodovale samo tri.

Moj prijedlog je da se boduje 5 recenzija s pripadajućim brojem bodova:5,4,3,2 i 1.

Je li to izvedivo? Ostala mišljenja?
Go to Top of Page

paro
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8618 Posts

Member since 30/03/2005

Posted - 03/02/2021 : 08:04:44  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit paro's Homepage  Send paro a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Ja sam protiv, oduvijek je bilo tri i zašto to mjenjat. Dobrih recenzija je bilo kroz ovih 11 godina ohohoho.
There he goes. One of God's own prototypes. A high-powered mutant of some kind never even considered for mass production. Too weird to live, and too rare to die.
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 176 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Previous Page | Next Page
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Jump To:
forum.stripovi.com © 2000-2002 Snitz Communications Go To Top Of Page
This page was generated in 0.53 seconds. Snitz Forums 2000