forum.stripovi.com
forum.stripovi.com
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Active Polls | Aukcije | Private Messages | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
 Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Stripovi
 Stripovi
 IZBOR ZA RECENZIJU MESECA		  New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Previous Page | Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 172

DinkoJ
New Member



238 Posts

Member since 09/11/2018

Posted - 18/02/2024 : 11:00:46  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send DinkoJ a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - STRIP ALBUM: Poglavica jelena by Salkan
4 boda - ZAGOR: Kuća užasa by igor 12
3 boda - JULIA: Sheilina duga noć by Ivan Liverpool
2 boda - KIT TELLER: Začarani kompas by ReemCP
1 bod - KIT TELLER: Južnjačko zlato by Spock
Go to Top of Page

Dwayne_Looney
Advanced Member



6884 Posts

Member since 15/10/2014

Posted - 22/02/2024 : 23:11:36  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Dwayne_Looney a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 - ZAGOR: Kuća užasa by igor 12
4 - KIT TELLER: Južnjačko zlato by Spock
3 - NATHAN NEVER: Rat za vodu by Jerry Krause
2 - STRIP ALBUM: Solitudinis morbus by Salkan
1 - JULIA: Sheilina duga noć by Ivan Liverpool
loading...
Edited by - Dwayne_Looney on 25/02/2024 10:35:12
Go to Top of Page

Deers
Advanced Member



Croatia
9402 Posts

Member since 29/03/2004

Posted - 23/02/2024 : 11:42:57  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Deers a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - JEDNO DOBA, JEDNA PRIČA: Povratak u Berlin by Dwayne_Looney
4 boda - STRIP ALBUM: Solitudinis morbus by Salkan
3 boda - TEX WILLER: Junak i legenda by prozirna senka
2 boda - NICK RAIDER: Duga noć by ReemCP
1 bod - STRIP ALBUM: Poglavica jelena by Salkan
"Trzaj mišica i nad prazninom sam."
Go to Top of Page

Altairfan
Junior Member



467 Posts

Member since 12/12/2019

Posted - 25/02/2024 : 12:44:14  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Altairfan a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 b - TEX WILLER: Spletka u Klondikeu by tex2
4 b - STRIP ALBUM: Poglavica jelena by Salkan
3 b - NICK RAIDER: Otrovnice iz močvare by ReemCP
2 b - TEX WILLER: Junak i legenda by prozirna senka
1 b - NATHAN NEVER: Rat za vodu by Jerry Krause
Go to Top of Page

Spock
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
7518 Posts

Member since 26/12/2006

Posted - 26/02/2024 : 13:36:27  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Spock a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - STRIP ALBUM: Solitudinis morbus by Salkan
4 boda - JEDNO DOBA, JEDNA PRIČA: Povratak u Berlin by Dwayne_Looney
3 boda - KIT TELLER: Riječna kraljica by ReemCP
2 boda - KIT TELLER: Začarani kompas by ReemCP
1 bod - KIT TELLER: Tajna jezera Bjukena by Salkan
Kamo god da kreneš, uvijek si tu.
Go to Top of Page

Ivan Liverpool
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
2321 Posts

Member since 10/04/2021

Posted - 28/02/2024 : 18:45:33  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Ivan Liverpool a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - Jedno doba, jedna prica: Povratak u Berlin
4 boda - Tex Willer: Spletka u Klondikeu
3 boda - Strip album: Solitudinis morbus
2 boda - Tex Willer: Ruke u plamenu
1 bod - Kit Teller: Zacarani kompas
"Losing is not my enemy. Fear of losing is my enemy."
Go to Top of Page

Dwayne_Looney
Advanced Member



6884 Posts

Member since 15/10/2014

Posted - 01/03/2024 : 14:07:05  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Dwayne_Looney a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Ponovno razočaran činjenicom da je u izboru za recenziju mjeseca sudjelovalo svega 6 forumaša, utvrđujem da je

POBJEDNIK 1. MJESECA 2024. GODINE (siječanj / januar)






JEDNO DOBA, JEDNA PRIČA: Povratak u Berlin by Dwayne_Looney






Iako bih volio da je broj glasača veći, hvala na glasovima zahvaljujući kojim je recenzija priče "Povratak u Berlin" izabrana za najbolju u siječnju.


Poveznica za recenziju mjeseca:
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/jedno-doba-jedna-prica-jdjp-drkw-6-povratak-u-berlin/3164/

Bodove forumaša je dobilo 15 od 22 recenzije, pa sam u utvrđivanju poretka često morao koristiti pravila.


Tablica za 1. mjesec 2024. godine:

1. JEDNO DOBA, JEDNA PRIČA: Povratak u Berlin by Dwayne_Looney - 16 bodova
2. STRIP ALBUM: Solitudinis morbus by Salkan - 15 bodova
3. STRIP ALBUM: Poglavica jelena by Salkan - 11 bodova
4. ZAGOR: Kuća užasa by igor 12 - 10 bodova*
5. TEX WILLER: Spletka u Kolondikeu by tex2 - 10 bodova*
6. KIT TELLER: Začarani kompas by ReemCP - 5 bodova**
7. KIT TELLER: Južnjačko zlato by Spock - 5 bodova**
8. TEX WILLER: Junak i legenda by prozirna senka - 5 bodova**
9. NATHAN NEVER: Rat za vodu by Jerry Krause - 4 boda***
10. JULIA: Sheilina duga noć by Ivan Liverpool - 4 boda***
11. KIT TELLER: Riječna kraljica by ReemCP - 3 boda****
12. NICK RAIDER: Otrovnice iz močvare by ReemCP - 3 boda****
13. NICK RAIDER: Duga noć by ReemCP - 2 boda*****
14. TEX WILLER: Ruke u plamenu by Koresh - 2 boda*****
15. KIT TELLER: Tajna jezera Bjukena by Salkan - 1 bod

* - obje recenzije su do bodova došle na isti način (zbroj 6+4) pa bolji plasman ide onoj koju je recenzirao autor koji dosad ima više objavljenih recenzija
** - za ReemCP-ovu recenziju je glasalo više glasača od preostale dvije (3), a Spockova je ispred senkine zbog pravila više većih bodova (zbroj 4+1 naspram 3+2)
*** - obje recenzije su do bodova došle na isti način pa je i ovdje kriterij u poretku bila "nagrada za životno djelo"
**** - do bodova jednim glasom, obje pisao isti autor, bolji plasman onoj koja je do danas skupila više komentara
***** - opet nagrada za životno djelo
loading...
Edited by - Dwayne_Looney on 01/03/2024 14:08:01
Go to Top of Page

ReemCP
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
13069 Posts

Member since 03/01/2018

Posted - 01/03/2024 : 14:10:13  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send ReemCP a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Čestitke Dwayne
Strike first. Strike hard. No mercy.
Go to Top of Page

Ivan Liverpool
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
2321 Posts

Member since 10/04/2021

Posted - 01/03/2024 : 14:14:53  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Ivan Liverpool a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Cestitke Dwayne!
"Losing is not my enemy. Fear of losing is my enemy."
Go to Top of Page

Spock
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
7518 Posts

Member since 26/12/2006

Posted - 01/03/2024 : 15:19:30  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Spock a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Opa, bravo Dwayne!
Kamo god da kreneš, uvijek si tu.
Go to Top of Page

Salkan
Average Member



Bosnia and Herzegovina
675 Posts

Member since 20/01/2021

Posted - 01/03/2024 : 15:21:07  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Salkan a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Čestitke Dwayneu!
Škafiškafnjak
Go to Top of Page

tex2
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
31018 Posts

Member since 17/09/2006

Posted - 01/03/2024 : 16:07:27  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send tex2 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Čestitke Dwayne!
"Od svakog treba tražiti samo ono što on može dati."
"The puck is in! The home team wins!", the good ol' hockey game
Go to Top of Page

Deers
Advanced Member



Croatia
9402 Posts

Member since 29/03/2004

Posted - 01/03/2024 : 16:20:34  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Deers a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Čestitam!
"Trzaj mišica i nad prazninom sam."
Go to Top of Page

Dwayne_Looney
Advanced Member



6884 Posts

Member since 15/10/2014

Posted - 01/03/2024 : 18:46:48  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Dwayne_Looney a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Hvala svima!

Uskoro otvaramo izbor za najbolju recenziju veljače.
loading...
Go to Top of Page

Dwayne_Looney
Advanced Member



6884 Posts

Member since 15/10/2014

Posted - 01/03/2024 : 20:51:04  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Dwayne_Looney a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Pred kraj prvog dana mjeseca, po običaju, otvaramo novi izbor. Sa željom da sudjelujete u većem broju nego protekla dva mjeseca, donosim recenzije koje smo mogli čitati u proteklih 29 dana.

IZBOR ZA NAJBOLJU RECENZIJU 2. MJESECA (veljača / februar)



VELIKI BLEK: Šume zasjeda by Ivan Liverpool
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/veliki-blek-vb-lu-13-sume-zasjeda/3171/

TEX WILLER: Dva dezertera by tex2
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/mladi-tex-willer-mtx-lib-2-dva-dezertera/3172/

ALAN FORD: Gužva u Monte Kablu by prozirna senka
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/alan-ford-af-sa-59-guzva-u-monte-kablu/3173/

KOMANDANT MARK: Fantomski brod by Ivan Liverpool
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-lu-5c-fantomski-brod/3174/

KOMANDANT MARK: Čovek bez lica by Salkan
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-lu-6a-covek-bez-lica/3175/

KOMANDANT MARK: Začarana hrid by Dwayne_Looney
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-lu-20a-zacarana-hrid/3176/

KOMANDANT MARK: Crvene strelice by Ivan Liverpool
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-lu-6b-crvene-strelice/3177/

KOMANDANT MARK: Most iznenađenja by Salkan
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-lu-6c-most-iznenadenja/3178/

GREYSTORM: Južni pol by prozirna senka
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/greystorm-gs-phpr-3-juzni-pol/3179/

NATHAN NEVER: Krik u tami by drogsy
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/nathan-never-nn-mx-4a-krik-u-tami/3180/

STRIP ALBUM: Amnezija mali by Deers
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/amnezija-mali-amnm-smzd-1-amnezija-mali/3181/

TEX WILLER: Lovci na buffale by tex2
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/tex-willer-tx-zs-609-lovci-na-buffale/3182/

MARTIN MYSTERE: Metuzalemov sindrom by prozirna senka
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/martin-mystere-mm-libg-13-metuzalemov-sindrom/3183/

VELIKI BLEK: Gusar Yorik by Ivan Liverpool
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/veliki-blek-vb-lu-14-gusar-yorik/3184/

ZAGOR: Na tragu titana by igor 12
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/zagor-zg-lex-46-47-na-tragu-titana/36/

KIT TELLER: Malajski bodež by Agencija Brandy JIMM
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/kit-teller-kt-vg-14b-malajski-bodez/3186/

MARTIN MYSTERE: Horizont događaja by Salkan
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/martin-mystere-mm-vec-33-horizont-dogadaja/3187/

DYLAN DOG: Netko u sjeni by Ivan Liverpool
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/dylan-dog-dd-alm-14-netko-u-sjeni/3188/

NICK RAIDER: Nestali Buda by ReemCP
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/nick-raider-nr-lib-15b-nestali-buda/3189/

KOMANDANT MARK: Nestanak svetog štita by Salkan
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-lu-7b-nestanak-svetog-stita/3190/

MARTIN MYSTERE: 29. veljače by Spock
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/martin-mystere-mm-sa-77-29-veljace/3191/




Za kraj riječ ima Spock u svom mjesečnom izvještaju...

quote:
Originally posted by Spock

Rezervacije i recenzije - mjesečni izvještaj za veljača (februar) 2024.


Broj novih rezervacija: 28

Nema posustajanja po pitanju recenzija, pa se stanje na lageru i dalje povećava, Reemovom ubrzanom ritmu objavljivanja unatoč. Tako na današnji dan imamo 77 neobjavljenih recenzija na lageru i gomilu novih rezervacija pouzdanih članova:

Salkan – 17 rezervacija: Šta reći? Sedamnaest novih rezervacija, a zadivljujuću raznolikost ne treba niti spominjati.
tex2 – 5 rezervacija: Tri Texa i dva Nicka su prošlomjesečni bilten rezervacija našega Texa.
Ivan Liverpool – 3 rezervacije: Ivan nastavlja s Texom i tri nove rezervacije globalno najpopularnijeg SBE junaka.
Koresh – 2 rezervacije: Koresh je opet zapeo ozbiljno po pitanju recenzija, pa smo prošli mjesec imali po jednu njegovu rezervaciju Texa i Diabolika
drogsy – 1 rezervacija: Vratio nam se i Drogsy nakon višemjesečnog izbivanja, ponovno s Nathanom.


Broj novih recenzija: 20+1

Uz produženi tjedan Komandanta Marka, imali smo i eksperimentalnih pola mjeseca misterija u ovom prijestupnom mjesecu. Zajednička poveznica tih stripova je bila misterija, pa je tako i naš Dobri Stari Stric Martin došao na svoje s tri recenzije u jednom mjesecu.

Po serijalima rezultat bi bio:

Komandant Mark - 6
Martin Mystere - 3
Veliki Blek - 2
Tex - 2
Nathan Never - 1
Kit Teller - 1
Nick Raider - 1
Greystorm - 1
Dylan Dog - 1
Amnezija mali - 1
Alan Ford - 1
+
Zagor (kontrarecenzija) - 1

Nakon što je prošli mjesec završio bez objavljene recenzije, Mark je ovaj mjesec zaslužio prvo mjesto sa čak šest novih recenzija, a Marty nakon dugo vremena ima veći broj recenzija u jednom mjesecu. Ovdje moram spomenuti recenziju jednog Alan Forda nakon sušne TRI godine, kao i recenziju stripa našeg kolege s foruma – Emira Pašanovića.

Po recenzentima situacija je:

Ivan Liverpool - 5 (Komandant Mark^2, Veliki Blek^2, Dylan Dog)
Salkan - 4 (Komandant Mark^3, Martin Mystere)
prozirna senka - 3 (Alan Ford, Martin Mystere, Greystorm)
tex2 - 2 (Tex, Mladi Tex)
ReemCP - 1 (Nick Raider)
drogsy - 1 (Nathan Never)
Spock - 1 (Martin Mystere)
Deers - 1 (Amnezija mali)
Dwayne_Looney - 1 (Komandant Mark)
igor 12 - 1 (Zagor kontrarecenzija)
Agencija Brandy JIMM - 1 (Kit Teller)

Ponovno imamo deset različitih recenzenata + udruženje četiri stalna recenzenta i zajedničko odrađivanje recenzije premijerne Nolittine epizode u Kitu Telleru. Zbog nemogućnosti proizvoljnog unosa imena recenzenta, ta recenzija je službeno pripisana Dwayne_Looneyju.

Ivan Liverpool je pobjednik mjeseca s pet recenzija za tri različita junaka, a Salkan je ovaj put ostao kratak za jednu recenziju, ali je zato rasturio s tri recenzije Kom. Marka u jednom mjesecu. To nismo imali još od vremena Herculovih recenzija istoga junaka (Hercule je znao imati i po četiri recenzije Marka mjesečno.)!

Broj komentara na recenzije: 435

Broj komentara je na razini prošlog mjeseca, ali bilo je puno ocjena bez komentara jednoga novog člana (reso1991).
Ivan Liverpool je opet bio u elementu s 96 komentara, pa tako ponovno imamo istoga prvoplasniranog na obje rubrike. Prošli mjesec je to bio Salkan s najviše objavljenih recenzija i komentara na recenzije.
loading...
Go to Top of Page

ReemCP
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
13069 Posts

Member since 03/01/2018

Posted - 02/03/2024 : 14:05:02  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send ReemCP a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - STRIP ALBUM: Amnezija mali by Deers
4 boda - KOMANDANT MARK: Fantomski brod by Ivan Liverpool
3 boda - ZAGOR: Na tragu titana by igor 12
2 boda - 29. veljače by Spock
1 bod - GREYSTORM: Južni pol by prozirna senka

(evo da se malo uključim u glasanje kad ih je već prošli mjesec bilo malo, rado bi glasao i za Malajski bodež, ali moram se suzdržati od glasanja jer sam i sam sudjelovao u tom projektu pa ne bi bilo fer da joj dajem bodove)
Strike first. Strike hard. No mercy.
Go to Top of Page

Deers
Advanced Member



Croatia
9402 Posts

Member since 29/03/2004

Posted - 02/03/2024 : 22:09:34  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Deers a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - GREYSTORM: Južni pol by prozirna senka
4 boda - MARTIN MYSTERE: 29. veljače by Spock
3 boda - MARTIN MYSTERE: Horizont događaja by Salkan
2 boda - NATHAN NEVER: Krik u tami by drogsy
1 bod - KIT TELLER: Malajski bodež by Agencija Brandy JIMM
"Trzaj mišica i nad prazninom sam."
Go to Top of Page

DinkoJ
New Member



238 Posts

Member since 09/11/2018

Posted - 17/03/2024 : 21:06:37  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send DinkoJ a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - ZAGOR: Na tragu titana by igor 12
4 boda - TEX WILLER: Lovci na buffale by tex2
3 boda - ALAN FORD: Gužva u Monte Kablu by prozirna senka
2 boda - VELIKI BLEK: Šume zasjeda by Ivan Liverpool
1 bod - VELIKI BLEK: Gusar Yorik by Ivan Liverpool
Go to Top of Page

Altairfan
Junior Member



467 Posts

Member since 12/12/2019

Posted - 24/03/2024 : 10:14:52  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Altairfan a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - TEX WILLER: Lovci na buffale by tex2
4 boda - DYLAN DOG: Netko u sjeni by Ivan Liverpool
3 boda - NICK RAIDER: Nestali Buda by ReemCP
2 boda - MARTIN MYSTERE: Horizont događaja by Salkan
1 bod - GREYSTORM: Južni pol by prozirna senka
Go to Top of Page

Spock
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
7518 Posts

Member since 26/12/2006

Posted - 24/03/2024 : 15:08:04  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Spock a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - STRIP ALBUM: Amnezija mali by Deers
4 boda - MARTIN MYSTERE: Horizont događaja by Salkan
3 boda - MARTIN MYSTERE: Metuzalemov sindrom by prozirna senka
2 boda - NICK RAIDER: Nestali Buda by ReemCP
1 bod - DYLAN DOG: Netko u sjeni by Ivan Liverpool
Kamo god da kreneš, uvijek si tu.
Edited by - Spock on 24/03/2024 15:08:22
Go to Top of Page

paro
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8583 Posts

Member since 30/03/2005

Posted - 27/03/2024 : 09:17:02  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit paro's Homepage  Send paro a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - GREYSTORM: Južni pol by prozirna senka
4 boda - NATHAN NEVER: Krik u tami by drogsy
3 boda - ALAN FORD: Gužva u Monte Kablu by prozirna senka
2 boda - TEX WILLER: Lovci na buffale by tex2
1 ubod - STRIP ALBUM: Amnezija mali by Deers
There he goes. One of God's own prototypes. A high-powered mutant of some kind never even considered for mass production. Too weird to live, and too rare to die.
Edited by - paro on 27/03/2024 09:18:39
Go to Top of Page

Jerry Krause
stripovi.com suradnik



Western Samoa
7269 Posts

Member since 12/11/2009

Posted - 27/03/2024 : 09:36:48  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Jerry Krause a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - Drogsyjev krik
4 boda - Senkina gužva
3 boda - Liverpoolov Yorik
2 boda - Reemov Buda
1 bod - Spockov 29. veljače
Go to Top of Page

Dwayne_Looney
Advanced Member



6884 Posts

Member since 15/10/2014

Posted - 31/03/2024 : 16:37:09  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Dwayne_Looney a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 - NATHAN NEVER: Krik u tami by drogsy
4 - GREYSTORM: Južni pol by prozirna senka
3 - STRIP ALBUM: Amnezija mali by Deers
2 - DYLAN DOG: Netko u sjeni by Ivan Liverpool
1 - MARTIN MYSTERE: 29. veljače by Spock
loading...
Go to Top of Page

Ivan Liverpool
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
2321 Posts

Member since 10/04/2021

Posted - 31/03/2024 : 19:36:15  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Ivan Liverpool a Private Message  Reply with Quote
6 bodova - Nathan Never: Krik u tami
4 boda - Tex Willer: Lovci na buffale
3 boda - Greystorm: Juzni pol
2 boda - Martin Mystere: 29. veljace
1 bod - Komandant Mark: Nestanak svetog stita
"Losing is not my enemy. Fear of losing is my enemy."
Go to Top of Page

Ernie Pike
Senior Member



Croatia
2849 Posts

Member since 06/03/2012

Posted - 31/03/2024 : 22:43:55  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Ernie Pike a Private Message  Reply with Quote
STRIP ALBUM: Amnezija mali by Deers - 6 bodova
KIT TELLER: Malajski bodež by Agencija Brandy JIMM - 4 boda
NATHAN NEVER: Krik u tami by drogsy - 3 boda
TEX WILLER: Lovci na buffale by tex2 - 2 boda
VELIKI BLEK: Gusar Yorik by Ivan Liverpool - 1 bod
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 172 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Previous Page | Next Page
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Jump To:
forum.stripovi.com © 2000-2002 Snitz Communications Go To Top Of Page
This page was generated in 0.41 seconds. Snitz Forums 2000