| Author |
 Topic  |
|
Tonto
Advanced Member
8975 Posts
Member since 11/02/2012 |
 Posted - 19/03/2024 : 08:24:59
|
quote:
Originally posted by fandango
Mad Max je postapokalipsa, a Children of Men distopija. U prvom se civilizacija urusila, a u drugom drustvo distorziralo. Svaki je dobar na svoj nacin, a to sto Mad Max nije nominiran, steta. Fury Road je nominiran pa nitko ne glasa.
Pa da, ali se podjednako imaju pravo smatrat sf-om. Stvar je u tome sto ih ljudi uglavnom ne percipiraju kao sf ili barem ne prvenstveno kao sf i zato nema toliko glasova za takvu vrstu filmova. |
The less I have the more I am a happy man |
 |
|
|
ridiculus
Senior Member
1811 Posts
Member since 11/06/2008 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 08:36:36
|
Pa prvi Mad Max se više bavi sudbinom jedne porodice, dok Children of Men sadrži pogled na sudbinu čovečanstva.
Čak i ja, koji zaista volim (skoro) čitav serijal Mad Max, čak i ja bih glasao za njega u okvirima akcionog žanra (gde nisam imao vremena da poređam favorite u listu, pa i nisam poređao). |
Thought's the slave of life, and life Time's fool. |
|
|
|
fandango
Senior Member
1693 Posts
Member since 10/06/2004 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 08:39:15
|
| Pa to je zato sto ljudi sf percipiraju prvenstveno i instinktivno kao nesto u svemiru, pa onda i de facto drame kao Gravity budu sf po defaultu percepcije, a sf-ovi kao Mad Max ili Children of Men (ili Pleme spiljskog medvjeda, morao sam) ne budu. |
|
|
|
vukozec
Advanced Member
5079 Posts
Member since 17/08/2013 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 08:50:44
|
12 Blade Runner 1982
10 2001: A Space Odyssey 1968
8 Logan's Run
7 Metropolis 1927
6 The Terminator 1984
5 Twelve monkeys
4 Forbidden Planet 1956
3 Planet of the Apes 1968
2 Alien 1979
1 Soylent Green |
Edited by - vukozec on 19/03/2024 16:31:33 |
|
|
|
alexts
Advanced Member
Serbia
9285 Posts
Member since 25/09/2005 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 08:51:33
|
quote:
Originally posted by fandango
Pa to je zato sto ljudi sf percipiraju prvenstveno i instinktivno kao nesto u svemiru
Pa koji su to ljudi? Neka površna publika? Ovde na forumu ima dosta ljudi i koji čitaju SF i dobro znaju da u SF može da uđe mnogo najrazličitijih stvari. |
|
|
|
vukozec
Advanced Member
5079 Posts
Member since 17/08/2013 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 08:58:29
|
Prvi Mad Max zapravo imam vrlo malo SF elemenata - prilično je nejasno u kojem trenutku i društvenom uređenju se radnja odvija, nepažljivom gledatelju gotovo da može promaći da to nije sadašnjost, no ipak je sve nekako pomaknuto pa nam je jasno da je riječ o distopiji.
Najizraženije SF elemente u MM franšizi naravno ima Road Warrior. Fury Road je prvenstveno akcijski film, smješten u MM univerzum, no i on ima nekih antropoloških "soft" SF elemenata, dakle sličniji je Herbertu nego Asimovu :)
|
|
|
|
alexts
Advanced Member
Serbia
9285 Posts
Member since 25/09/2005 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 09:07:37
|
quote:
Originally posted by vukozec
Prvi Mad Max zapravo imam vrlo malo SF elemenata - prilično je nejasno u kojem trenutku i društvenom uređenju se radnja odvija, nepažljivom gledatelju gotovo da može promaći da to nije sadašnjost, no ipak je sve nekako pomaknuto pa nam je jasno da je riječ o distopiji.
Najizraženije SF elemente u MM franšizi naravno ima Road Warrior. Fury Road je prvenstveno akcijski film, smješten u MM univerzum, no i on ima nekih antropoloških "soft" SF elemenata, dakle sličniji je Herbertu nego Asimovu :)
Slažem se.
Kao dječarac, ja sam mislio da se Mad Max dešava u Australiji, u vreme kad je i snimljen film. |
|
|
|
fandango
Senior Member
1693 Posts
Member since 10/06/2004 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 09:12:50
|
Koji ste vi to film gledali kad prvi Mad Max pocinje natpisom "A few years from now..."? 
Sto se tice odgovora na pitanje koji su to ljudi, ne znam, procijeni sam, kao sto sam i ja procijenio to koji su to ljudi kad je Tonto napisao "ljudi". |
|
|
|
gaspa127
Average Member
551 Posts
Member since 11/11/2022 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 09:46:02
|
12 Inception
10 The Prestige
8 The Fifth Element
7 Demolition Man
6 Total recall (1990)
5 Robocop
4 The Matrix
3 Alien
2 Planet of the Apes (1968)
1 Avatar
|
|
|
|
Shaner
Advanced Member
Croatia
7693 Posts
Member since 24/09/2012 |
|
|
fandango
Senior Member
1693 Posts
Member since 10/06/2004 |
|
|
sawitch
Advanced Member
Serbia
41211 Posts
Member since 17/11/2007 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 13:53:36
|
quote:
Originally posted by vukozec
12 Blade Runner 1982
10 2001: A Space Odyssey 1968
8 Mad Max 2 1981
7 Metropolis 1927
6 The Terminator 1984
5 Twelve monkeys
4 Forbidden Planet 1956
3 Planet of the Apes 1968
2 Alien 1979
1 Soylent Green
Mad Max 2 nije nominovan |
Patricia hic mea totus mundus est |
|
|
|
sawitch
Advanced Member
Serbia
41211 Posts
Member since 17/11/2007 |
|
|
sawitch
Advanced Member
Serbia
41211 Posts
Member since 17/11/2007 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 15:36:28
|
12 - Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope
10 - Star Wars: Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back
8 - The Terminator 2
7 - The Matrix
6 - The Fifth Element
5 - Avatar
4 - Pitch Black
3 - Dune: Part 2
2 - Stargate
1 - Independence Day |
Patricia hic mea totus mundus est |
|
|
|
vukozec
Advanced Member
5079 Posts
Member since 17/08/2013 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 16:31:13
|
quote:
Originally posted by sawitch
quote:
Originally posted by vukozec
12 Blade Runner 1982
10 2001: A Space Odyssey 1968
8 Mad Max 2 1981
7 Metropolis 1927
6 The Terminator 1984
5 Twelve monkeys
4 Forbidden Planet 1956
3 Planet of the Apes 1968
2 Alien 1979
1 Soylent Green
Mad Max 2 nije nominovan
Šteta. U tom slučaju neka bude 8 bodova za... Jenny Agutter! :)
Evo, editirano. |
|
|
|
naker
Advanced Member
5674 Posts
Member since 05/06/2020 |
Posted - 19/03/2024 : 22:16:24
|
12 - 2001: A Space Odyssey
10 - Alien
8 - Blade Runner
7 - Ghost in the Shell
6 - Matrix
5 - Terminator 2
4 - Stalker
3 - Solaris '72
2 - Star Wars: Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back
1 - Dune: Part Two |
|
|
|
sawitch
Advanced Member
Serbia
41211 Posts
Member since 17/11/2007 |
Posted - 20/03/2024 : 13:11:57
|
quote:
Originally posted by vukozec
Šteta. U tom slučaju neka bude 8 bodova za... Jenny Agutter! :)
Evo, editirano.
Druze, nema ni ovog. Pocnem da unosim pa brisem. Hajde pogledaj nominacije pa izaberi filmove i stavi na listu. Nema smisla ovako. |
Patricia hic mea totus mundus est |
|
|
|
Tonto
Advanced Member
8975 Posts
Member since 11/02/2012 |
Posted - 20/03/2024 : 13:16:51
|
quote:
Originally posted by sawitch
quote:
Originally posted by vukozec
Šteta. U tom slučaju neka bude 8 bodova za... Jenny Agutter! :)
Evo, editirano.
Druze, nema ni ovog. Pocnem da unosim pa brisem. Hajde pogledaj nominacije pa izaberi filmove i stavi na listu. Nema smisla ovako.
ma misli na logan's run, to je glumica |
The less I have the more I am a happy man |
|
|
|
Mr. Bushido
stripovi.com suradnik
Croatia
12974 Posts
Member since 23/09/2005 |
Posted - 20/03/2024 : 14:03:42
|
12 - Star Wars: Episode IV - A New Hope
10 - Robocop
08 - Back to the Future
07 - Turbo Kid
06 - Aliens
05 - Children of Men
04 - Starship Troopers
03 - Star Wars: Episode VIII - The Last Jedi
02 - Inception
01 - Her
|
Comics is any art you can read. -- Sean T. Collins |
|
|
|
sawitch
Advanced Member
Serbia
41211 Posts
Member since 17/11/2007 |
Posted - 20/03/2024 : 14:46:06
|
quote:
Originally posted by Tonto
quote:
Originally posted by sawitch
quote:
Originally posted by vukozec
Šteta. U tom slučaju neka bude 8 bodova za... Jenny Agutter! :)
Evo, editirano.
Druze, nema ni ovog. Pocnem da unosim pa brisem. Hajde pogledaj nominacije pa izaberi filmove i stavi na listu. Nema smisla ovako.
ma misli na logan's run, to je glumica
A jbt, kako ja to da znam. Ne znam sto je tesko ispisati sve kako treba... Hvala Tonto. |
Patricia hic mea totus mundus est |
|
|
|
sawitch
Advanced Member
Serbia
41211 Posts
Member since 17/11/2007 |
|
|
alexts
Advanced Member
Serbia
9285 Posts
Member since 25/09/2005 |
Posted - 20/03/2024 : 15:02:48
|
quote:
Originally posted by sawitch
quote:
Originally posted by Tonto
quote:
Originally posted by sawitch
quote:
Originally posted by vukozec
Šteta. U tom slučaju neka bude 8 bodova za... Jenny Agutter! :)
Evo, editirano.
Druze, nema ni ovog. Pocnem da unosim pa brisem. Hajde pogledaj nominacije pa izaberi filmove i stavi na listu. Nema smisla ovako.
ma misli na logan's run, to je glumica
A jbt, kako ja to da znam. Ne znam sto je tesko ispisati sve kako treba... Hvala Tonto.
Editirano - mislio je u originalnom postu sa predlozima. |
|
|
|
vukozec
Advanced Member
5079 Posts
Member since 17/08/2013 |
Posted - 20/03/2024 : 16:08:39
|
quote:
Originally posted by sawitch
quote:
Originally posted by Tonto
quote:
Originally posted by sawitch
quote:
Originally posted by vukozec
Šteta. U tom slučaju neka bude 8 bodova za... Jenny Agutter! :)
Evo, editirano.
Druze, nema ni ovog. Pocnem da unosim pa brisem. Hajde pogledaj nominacije pa izaberi filmove i stavi na listu. Nema smisla ovako.
ma misli na logan's run, to je glumica
A jbt, kako ja to da znam. Ne znam sto je tesko ispisati sve kako treba... Hvala Tonto.
Pa napisao sam da sam editirao, znači editiran je originalni post :) |
|
|
|
ken2
stripovi.com suradnik
Croatia
8240 Posts
Member since 30/07/2002 |
Posted - 20/03/2024 : 17:16:31
|
12 - blade runner
10 - 2001 odiseja u svemiru
8 - gattaca
7 - paklena naranča
6 - stalker
5 - kontakt
4 - 12 majmuna
3 - looper
2 - the abyss
1 - loganov bijeg
puno dragih filmova ipak otpalo |
if you tolerate this, then your children will be next |
|
|
|
Dr.GonZo
Senior Member
Croatia
1230 Posts
Member since 31/03/2002 |
|
|
Topic |
|
STRIPOVI.COM OSKAR
