forum.stripovi.com
forum.stripovi.com
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Active Polls | Aukcije | Private Messages | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
 Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Stripovi
 Stripovi
 TOP 100 scenarista GLASANJE za ENG do 24.9.		  New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Previous Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 6

don_draper
Advanced Member



4155 Posts

Member since 08/06/2018

Posted - 19/09/2024 : 06:03:10  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send don_draper a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Evo kod sebe sam izmijenio, nekako sam vec od ranije slozio taj poredak pa sam smetnuo s uma da ce biti lakse da drugi sudionici stave isto tako bodove. Hvala na podsjetniku.
I sell the fact that I can't be bought
Go to Top of Page

Beva
Advanced Member



Bosnia and Herzegovina
5803 Posts

Member since 04/06/2007

Posted - 19/09/2024 : 07:24:37  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Beva a Private Message  Reply with Quote
1.Alan Moore 18
2.Neil Gaiman 16
3.Robert Kirkman 14
4.Joe Hill 12
5.Michel Rabagliati 11
6.Art Spiegelman 10
7.Garth Ennis 9
8.Bill Watterson 8
9.Eisner Will 7
10.Brian K Vaughan 6
11.Stan Sakai 5
12.Carl Barks 4
13.Charles Schulz 3
14.Hernandez bros 2
15.Harvey Kurtzman 1
Jubilarni Polo 10!http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=51213
Go to Top of Page

King Warrior
stripovi.com suradnik



22288 Posts

Member since 10/11/2007

Posted - 19/09/2024 : 10:51:19  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send King Warrior a Private Message  Reply with Quote
1.Garth Ennis 18
2.Frank Miller 16
3.Robert Kirkman 14
4.Alan Moore 12
5.Grant Morrison 11
6.Brian K Vaughan 10
7.Hal Foster 9
8.Warren Ellis 8
9.Neil Gaiman 7
10.Eisner Will 6
11.Mignola Mike 5
12.Kurt Busiek 4
13.Joe Hill 3
14.Mark Waid 2
15.Sergio Aragones 1
Go to Top of Page

naker
Advanced Member



4215 Posts

Member since 05/06/2020

Posted - 19/09/2024 : 12:47:22  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send naker a Private Message  Reply with Quote
18 - Alan Moore
16 - Frank Miller
14 - Garth Ennis
12 - Neil Gaiman
11 - Grant Morrison
10 - Warren Ellis
9 - Mignola Mike
8 - Bill Watterson
7 - Charles Schulz
6 - Carl Barks
5 - Don Rosa
4 - Jeph Loeb
3 - Jeff Smith
2 - Brian Azzarello
1 - Darwin Cooke
Go to Top of Page

Red Marquis
Advanced Member



Serbia
3238 Posts

Member since 06/11/2017

Posted - 19/09/2024 : 14:19:09  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Red Marquis a Private Message  Reply with Quote
1.Alan Moore 18
2.Peter Bagge 16
3.Hal Foster 14
4.Robert Crumb 12
5.Joe Sacco 11
6.Derf Backderf 10
7.Frank Miller 9
8.Guy Delisle 8
9.Bill Watterson 7
10.Joe Matt 6
11.Julia Wertz 5
12.Bryan Talbot 4
13.Jason Lutes 3
14.Jeph Loeb 2
15.Art Spiegelman 1
Go to Top of Page

Zula
Average Member

977 Posts

Member since 07/10/2015

Posted - 19/09/2024 : 22:30:08  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Zula a Private Message  Reply with Quote
18 Alan Moore
16 Neil Gaiman
14 Frank Miller
12 David Mazzucchelli
11 Art Siegelman
10 Jason Aaron
09 Hernandez bros
08 Garth Ennis
07 Mike Mignola
06 Jeph Loeb
05 Ed Brubaker
04 Jason Lutes
03 Joe Hill
02 Brian Azzarello
01 Joe Sacco
Go to Top of Page

Shaner
Advanced Member

Croatia
7180 Posts

Member since 24/09/2012

Posted - 19/09/2024 : 23:44:30  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Shaner a Private Message  Reply with Quote
1. Alan Moore 18
2. Hernandez bros 16
3. Carl Barks 14
4. Will Eisner 12
5. Frank Miller 11
6. David Mazzucchelli 10
7. Charles Burns 9
8. Jim Davis 8
9. Bill Watterson 7
10. Brian K Vaughan 6
11. Joe Sacco 5
12. Art Spiegelman 4
13. Chris Ware 3
14. Jason Lutes 2
15. Peter O'Donnell 1
http://onlineimpressions.blogspot.com/
Go to Top of Page

Shaner
Advanced Member

Croatia
7180 Posts

Member since 24/09/2012

Posted - 19/09/2024 : 23:50:49  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Shaner a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Nego, sad skužio da kod dvije manje kategorije prvo mjesto donosi 10 bodova što ih stavlja u podređenu poziciju kod sastavljanja ultimativne top 100 liste.
http://onlineimpressions.blogspot.com/
Go to Top of Page

Mr. Bushido
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
12889 Posts

Member since 23/09/2005

Posted - 20/09/2024 : 00:55:12  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Mr. Bushido a Private Message  Reply with Quote
01. Grant Morrison 18
02. Mark Waid 16
03. Gail Simone 14
04. Garth Ennis 12
05. John Ostrander 11
06. Ed Brubaker 10
07. Carl Barks 9
08. Alan Moore 8
09. Kurt Busiek 7
10. J.M. DeMatteis 6
11. Chris Claremont 5
12. Jack Kirby 4
13. Greg Rucka 3
14. Tom King 2
15. Kieron Gillen 1
Comics is any art you can read. -- Sean T. Collins
Go to Top of Page

Tonto
Advanced Member



8151 Posts

Member since 11/02/2012

Posted - 20/09/2024 : 02:01:55  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Tonto a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Alan Moore 18
Frank Miller 16
Neil Gaiman 14
Roy Thomas 12
Waren Ellis 11
Joe Hill 10
Bill Waterson 9
Jason Lutes 8
Bryan Talbot 7
Peter O'Donnel 6
Garth Ennis 5
Mike Mignola 4
Milton Caniff 3
Jeff Lemire 2
Mark Millar 1
The less I have the more I am a happy man
Go to Top of Page

paro
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8553 Posts

Member since 30/03/2005

Posted - 20/09/2024 : 04:25:35  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit paro's Homepage  Send paro a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Alan Moore 18
Neil Gaiman 16
Grant Morrison 14
Garth Ennis 12
Brian Azzarello 11
Jack Kirby 10
Robert Crumb 9
Gilbert Shelton 8
Sergio Aragones 7
Charles Schulz 6
Bill Watterson 5
Frank Miller 4
Stan Sakai 3
David Mazzucchelli 2
Stan Lee 1
There he goes. One of God's own prototypes. A high-powered mutant of some kind never even considered for mass production. Too weird to live, and too rare to die.
Edited by - paro on 20/09/2024 04:26:06
Go to Top of Page

don_draper
Advanced Member



4155 Posts

Member since 08/06/2018

Posted - 20/09/2024 : 05:59:50  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send don_draper a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Shaner

Nego, sad skužio da kod dvije manje kategorije prvo mjesto donosi 10 bodova što ih stavlja u podređenu poziciju kod sastavljanja ultimativne top 100 liste.




Za potrebe te ultimativne top 100 ljestvice njihovi bodovi ce biti pomnozeni tzv. "koeficijentom razlike" koji ce biti otprilike 1.8
I sell the fact that I can't be bought
Go to Top of Page

AdamEer
New Member



Bosnia and Herzegovina
118 Posts

Member since 02/06/2014

Posted - 20/09/2024 : 09:25:01  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit AdamEer's Homepage  Send AdamEer a Private Message  Reply with Quote
1. Alan Moore 18
2. Warren Ellis 16
3. Brian K Vaughan 14
4. Garth Ennis 12
5. Neil Gaiman 11
6. Grant Morrison 10
7. Frank Miller 9
8. Brian Michael Bendis 8
9. Brian Azzarello 7
10.Mark Waid 6
11.Ed Brubaker 5
12.Peter David 4
13.Paul Dini 3
14.Hernandez bros 2
15.Joe Sacco 1

P.S. Ne mogu da vjerujem da niko nije nominirao David Laphama (uključujući i mene)
https://globalcomix.com/c/spiral-down
www.instagram.com/ademirsabic
Go to Top of Page

Zula
Average Member

977 Posts

Member since 07/10/2015

Posted - 20/09/2024 : 09:55:24  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Zula a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Mogao je biti nominiran i Bill Willingham...
Go to Top of Page

Shaner
Advanced Member

Croatia
7180 Posts

Member since 24/09/2012

Posted - 20/09/2024 : 23:49:52  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Shaner a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by don_draper

quote:
Originally posted by Shaner

Nego, sad skužio da kod dvije manje kategorije prvo mjesto donosi 10 bodova što ih stavlja u podređenu poziciju kod sastavljanja ultimativne top 100 liste.




Za potrebe te ultimativne top 100 ljestvice njihovi bodovi ce biti pomnozeni tzv. "koeficijentom razlike" koji ce biti otprilike 1.8

Pošteno.

http://onlineimpressions.blogspot.com/
Go to Top of Page

anto
Advanced Member



Serbia
20953 Posts

Member since 29/06/2008

Posted - 20/09/2024 : 23:50:03  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send anto a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Alan Mur 18
Frenk Miler 16
E.C.Segar 14
Stan Sakai 12
Flojd Gotferdson 11
Harold Foster 10
Aleks Rejmond 9
Džef Lemir 8
Penis Gart 7
Robet Kirkmen 6
Džejson Aron 5
Bil Voterson 4
Brajan Von 3
Milton Kanif 2
Darvin Kuk 1
Dajte nam Ralph Azhama;može i mekokoricen (ali u boji obavezno)!
Edited by - anto on 21/09/2024 23:15:27
Go to Top of Page

Shuckey
Average Member



Croatia
719 Posts

Member since 18/12/2008

Posted - 21/09/2024 : 10:51:24  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Shuckey a Private Message  Reply with Quote
18 Alan Moore jer je najbolji
16 John Wagner 2000AD je ekstrakt i uzor
14 Pat Mills vidi gore, ali mi je Wagner draži
12 Garth Ennis uvijek zabavan i smiješan
11 Mark Millar vidi gore
10 Robert Kirkman Živi mrtvaci, Nepobedivi
9 Neil Gaiman Sandman, Miracleman, pozitiva i dobrota
8 Frank Miller jedini crtač tute, zna poso
7 Mark Waid gikčina i radilica
6 Grant Morrison violina sa tri žice ali dobro gudi
5 Brian Azzarello mjestimično odvratan, ostatak drži nivo
4 Ed Brubaker krimić gikčina
3 Brian Michael Bendis zbog Marvela
2 Brian K Vaughan lijepo prede duge priče i produktivan je
1 Marv Wolfman najveća gikčina i usto legenda
Hrvoje Bratanic AKA Šuki
Go to Top of Page

ridiculus
Senior Member



1659 Posts

Member since 11/06/2008

Posted - 21/09/2024 : 11:57:30  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send ridiculus a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Kod mene velike nedoumice, ali uspeh nekako. Titanska borba! Carl Barks protiv Stana Leeja! Claremont protiv Gaimana! Tri puta su menjali mesta, dok nisu završili tu gde su sada. Četiri puta se Lord Vader okrenuo čitajući ovo gore! Kako mogu uopšte da se pitam da li je Barks bolji od Leeja? Kvantna mizantropija! Štono kaže Victor Hugo, lavina protiv groma! Kako smrtni čovek to da izmeri?

Zasnovao sam listu na sposobnosti da se piše i za druge (a ne za sebe), na univerzalnosti, na raznovrsnosti, na uticaju i značaju (a ne popularnosti), to jest, koliko sam sposoban sve to da vidim iz svoje pozicije (= relativno malo, ali šta je tu je).

18 Alan Moore - prvosveštenik stripa, il maestro altissimo
16 Howard Chaykin - pop-arhitekta
14 Grant Morrison - razmaženi aristokrata, ali jedinstven poput amazonskih pečuraka
12 Frank Miller - buntovnik, pravednik, sam svoj osvetnik
11 Chris Claremont - tinejdžer, topdžija, superheroj, špijun
10 Neil Gaiman - romantizam u stripu, 200 godina kasnije
9 John Ostrander - Šekspir u stripu, o stripu
8 Leonard Starr - pozornica na listu papira
7 Archie Goodwin - jack-of-all-genres, urednik par excellence
6 Carl Barks - enciklopedista večnog šarma
5 Stan Lee - sa većom moći veća govorljivost
4 Walter Simonson - mitoman, fanatik, ekscentrik
3 Hal Foster - "ja na dvoru kralja Artura"
2 Kurt Busiek - večiti sjaj stripofilnog uma
1 Stan Sakai - olovka je oružje samuraja


A sada, kao što je unapred rastrubljeno, evo 5 najiritantnijih, u obrnutom redosledu, od najmanjeg stepena do najvišeg!

5. Matt Fraction
4. Bendis
3. Roy Thomas
2. Scott Snyder

(ovde ide podosta prostora)

1. Mark Millar

Treba li da se pravdam?

Shuckey ga je visoko stavio - time je provalije dublja, Shuckey! kod Millara se uvek gleda dole, a ne gore, Shuckey! - ali tu mu je i Mills, pa ću zažmuriti. (Iako ne vidim ni Millsa kao "velikog scenaristu"; to je pank, anarhija, haotičnost, te nema tu mnogo planiranja, to jest, scenarija; ali rezultat je obično sjajan, pa jedno "neka bude".)
Thought's the slave of life, and life Time's fool.
Go to Top of Page

Lord Vader89
stripovi.com suradnik



France
9590 Posts

Member since 05/07/2007

Posted - 21/09/2024 : 12:22:02  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Lord Vader89 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by ridiculus

5 Stan Lee - sa većom moći veća govorljivost


zbog ovoga na sve žmurim i sve praštam xD
Potpis u dva reda, prema pravilniku:
Vader je, kao i uvek, u pravu. ; john connor ; 2022 A.D.
Go to Top of Page

izivko
Advanced Member



Germany
12287 Posts

Member since 25/07/2003

Posted - 21/09/2024 : 14:16:51  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send izivko a Private Message  Reply with Quote
1. Will Eisner 18
2. Frank Miller 16
3. Alan Moore 14
4. Sergio Aragones 12
5. Garth Ennis 11
6. Howard Chaykin 10
7. Robert Crumb 9
8. Bill Waterson 8
9. Barry Windsor-Smith 7
10. Stan Sakai 6
11. Ed Brubaker 5
12. Mike Mignola 4
13. Gilbert Shelton 3
14. Brian Azzarello 2
15. Craig P. Russell 1
Have mercy
Go to Top of Page

don_draper
Advanced Member



4155 Posts

Member since 08/06/2018

Posted - 21/09/2024 : 23:05:21  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send don_draper a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by anto

Alan Mur 18
Frenk Miler 16
E.C.Segar 14
Stan Sakai 12
Flojd Gotferdson 11
Harold Foster 10
Aleks Rejmond 9
Penis Gart 7
Robet Kirkmen 6
Džejson Aron 5
Bil Voterson 4
Brajan Von 3
Milton Kanif 2
Darvin Kuk 1


Nedostaje ti još jedan da upotpuniš top 15, tako da ne znam je li zabuna ili ne. Ako je 14 njih namjerno onda je bodovanje drukčije.
I sell the fact that I can't be bought
Go to Top of Page

anto
Advanced Member



Serbia
20953 Posts

Member since 29/06/2008

Posted - 21/09/2024 : 23:14:17  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send anto a Private Message  Reply with Quote
sad ću ispraviti

edit:ispravljeno
Dajte nam Ralph Azhama;može i mekokoricen (ali u boji obavezno)!
Edited by - anto on 21/09/2024 23:15:59
Go to Top of Page

alexts
Advanced Member



Serbia
7548 Posts

Member since 25/09/2005

Posted - 21/09/2024 : 23:26:46  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send alexts a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Rejmond nije pisao Ripa Kirbija. Gotfredson je samo na početku par godina pisao Mikija.
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 6 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Previous Page
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Jump To:
forum.stripovi.com © 2000-2002 Snitz Communications Go To Top Of Page
This page was generated in 0.14 seconds. Snitz Forums 2000