forum.stripovi.com
forum.stripovi.com
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Active Polls | Aukcije | Private Messages | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 www.stripovi.com - svaštara - off topic diskusije
 Film & TV
 Di dajrektors gejm - rezultati
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Previous Page | Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 7

hello
Senior Member



Croatia
2731 Posts

Member since 14/07/2006

Posted - 13/01/2013 : 19:05:20  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit hello's Homepage  Send hello a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Eastwood +
Croneberg -
Allen -

www.izdavanje-knjiga-dani.hr
www.vangogh.hr
Go to Top of Page

maddox031
Senior Member

Croatia
1941 Posts

Member since 23/09/2011

Posted - 13/01/2013 : 19:08:44  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit maddox031's Homepage  Send maddox031 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Tarantino +

Del toro -
Hill -

There can be only one, me!
Go to Top of Page

corto33
Senior Member



Slovenia
2541 Posts

Member since 18/11/2003

Posted - 14/01/2013 : 08:53:36  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send corto33 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Michael Haneke +

Quentin Tarantino -
Tim Burton -

(trebao bi biti i Miike na listi ...)


Društvo ljubiteljev stripov Stripoholik
Go to Top of Page

DeeCay
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
21661 Posts

Member since 24/09/2002

Posted - 14/01/2013 : 11:20:54  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send DeeCay a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Ma kud puklo da puklo...

Srđan Dragojević & Chan-wook Park -
Tarantino +

“A reader lives a thousand lives before he dies; the man who never reads lives only one."
Go to Top of Page

kiky
stripovi.com suradnik



7366 Posts

Member since 17/07/2003

Posted - 14/01/2013 : 17:58:10  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit kiky's Homepage  Send kiky a Private Message  Reply with Quote
haneke +
burton -
guilermo del toro -
Go to Top of Page

tinton
stripovi.com suradnik

United Kingdom
19799 Posts

Member since 23/10/2011

Posted - 14/01/2013 : 19:19:39  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send tinton a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Miloš Forman +
Tim Burton -
Walter Hill -



Dajte nam Banija Libre;može i mekokoricen (ali u boji obavezno)!
Go to Top of Page

fandango
Senior Member



1638 Posts

Member since 10/06/2004

Posted - 14/01/2013 : 19:36:12  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send fandango a Private Message  Reply with Quote
István Szabó +
Srđan Dragojević -
Almodóvar -
Go to Top of Page

mcn
Advanced Member



Croatia
6666 Posts

Member since 28/12/2002

Posted - 14/01/2013 : 23:07:49  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit mcn's Homepage  Send mcn a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Do ovdje je prebrojeno.

mcn

Zar danas još niste bili na www.darkomacan.com ? *** Moje aukcije: http://www.stripovi.com/index.asp?page=auction-search&Action=1&Seller=mcn
Go to Top of Page

Darth Ivan
Advanced Member



Croatia
7978 Posts

Member since 21/03/2010

Posted - 14/01/2013 : 23:14:39  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Darth Ivan a Private Message  Reply with Quote
jedno pitanje:

mi u svakom krugu moramo glasat za druge redatelje?

ne znam, netko npr. u prvom krugu da Tarantinu +, i onda on njemu u idućem krugu ne može opet dat plus, nego se mora odlučit za druga tri?

"Nothing lasts forever."

Edited by - Darth Ivan on 14/01/2013 23:16:14
Go to Top of Page

mcn
Advanced Member



Croatia
6666 Posts

Member since 28/12/2002

Posted - 14/01/2013 : 23:16:07  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit mcn's Homepage  Send mcn a Private Message  Reply with Quote
>mi u svakom krugu moramo glasat za druge redatelje?

Ne, puno mi je to posla za kontrolirat, a i zašto: ako netko hoće svoj glas uvijek dati istome, neka mu daje.

mcn

Zar danas još niste bili na www.darkomacan.com ? *** Moje aukcije: http://www.stripovi.com/index.asp?page=auction-search&Action=1&Seller=mcn
Go to Top of Page

Darth Ivan
Advanced Member



Croatia
7978 Posts

Member since 21/03/2010

Posted - 14/01/2013 : 23:16:58  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Darth Ivan a Private Message  Reply with Quote
ok, pitam samo...

"Nothing lasts forever."
Go to Top of Page

mcn
Advanced Member



Croatia
6666 Posts

Member since 28/12/2002

Posted - 14/01/2013 : 23:20:38  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit mcn's Homepage  Send mcn a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Darth Ivan

ok, pitam samo...


Odgovaram samo ...

mcn

Zar danas još niste bili na www.darkomacan.com ? *** Moje aukcije: http://www.stripovi.com/index.asp?page=auction-search&Action=1&Seller=mcn
Go to Top of Page

mcn
Advanced Member



Croatia
6666 Posts

Member since 28/12/2002

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 03:46:52  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit mcn's Homepage  Send mcn a Private Message  Reply with Quote
I eto - gotovo! (for the record, moj glas u trećem krugu je K-Duk +, a Fincher i Del Toro -).

Hvala svima na igranju. Ja sam dobio što sam htio - popis više ili manje relevantnih prezimena da vidim što sam propustio - a uvijek se može raspravljati jesu li bitniji oni koji su mirno ostali na listi ili oni oko kojih se najviše klalo.

Jesu li ispuštena neka imena? Svakako. No, to je demokracija na djelu - nesavršen sistem daje nesavršene rezultate. Uostalom, zato sam u naslov i stavio "gejm" a ne neku ozbiljnije zvučeću odrednicu.

No, najozbiljnije; hvala svima na igranju!

(mcn)

Zar danas još niste bili na www.darkomacan.com ? *** Moje aukcije: http://www.stripovi.com/index.asp?page=auction-search&Action=1&Seller=mcn
Go to Top of Page

trolodtroje
Advanced Member

3277 Posts

Member since 14/09/2010

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 07:15:06  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send trolodtroje a Private Message  Reply with Quote
E sad imam homework da saznam malo više o:

Michael Haneke (6 bodova) mcn
Robert Benton (2 boda) Rommel
Kim Ki-Duk (3 boda) Poli
Istvan Szabo (2 boda) rommel

Možda sam nekad i čuo nešto o ovim redateljskim trustovima, ali ruku na srce - za nijednog od ovih ne mogu napamet da smislim neki njihov film. MCN - kad če drugo bianje bez ovih ovde? Ima još zilijon redatelja, koji bi mirne duše mogao proglasiti boljim od ovih.
Go to Top of Page

Poli
Advanced Member



Slovenia
38181 Posts

Member since 26/10/2007

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 08:17:32  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Poli a Private Message  Reply with Quote

He he, cisto spekuliram, ali zanimljivo bi bilo vidjeti kako bi se Haneke odrezao da ga Macan kao prvi nije predlozio. Vjerujem da bi sigurno zavrsio na listi, ali koliko bodova bi pokupio...



Anything is possible dec d uej
Be the Change You Want to See
Go to Top of Page

maddox031
Senior Member

Croatia
1941 Posts

Member since 23/09/2011

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 08:41:56  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit maddox031's Homepage  Send maddox031 a Private Message  Reply with Quote
od svakog koji su ostali pogledao barem jedan film :D

There can be only one, me!
Go to Top of Page

mcn
Advanced Member



Croatia
6666 Posts

Member since 28/12/2002

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 11:58:32  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit mcn's Homepage  Send mcn a Private Message  Reply with Quote
> Vjerujem da bi sigurno zavrsio na listi, ali koliko bodova bi pokupio...

Nije bitno, zato ih nisam ni posložio po bodovima nego s minimumom 2 - glas i podrška. A predložio sam ga prvog jer je a) trebalo od nekoga početi i b) činio mi se neupitnim (kao i Von Trier, recimo, a i neki koji su ispali).

Metoda eliminiranja onih s jednom glasom je tu da ukloni one koje voli uzak krug (bez obzira na kvalitetu).

Da, još jedan zaključak: vidjelo se u procesu glasanja određeno klanje između onih koje vole komercijalnije i autorskije pristupe. To je isto bilo za očekivati, ali nije se moglo izbjeći bez dodatnog kompliciranja (recimo "moraju i pisati svoje filmove") koje bi razdvojilo autore od manirista il' stilista, ali bi previše navlačilo vodu na mlin onih koje preferiram.

Novu igru može raditi netko drugi jer bi meni bila tlaka, a ne igra.

(mcn)

Zar danas još niste bili na www.darkomacan.com ? *** Moje aukcije: http://www.stripovi.com/index.asp?page=auction-search&Action=1&Seller=mcn

Edited by - mcn on 16/01/2013 12:00:18
Go to Top of Page

mcn
Advanced Member



Croatia
6666 Posts

Member since 28/12/2002

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 12:06:10  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit mcn's Homepage  Send mcn a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Eh, još jedan zaključak: kad nisu prisiljeni (revoltom ili pravilima) ljudi više vole davati pluseve nego minuseve. To je glede Hanekea, ali i nekonfrontativne psihe civiliziranoga čovjeka.

Ja naravno potičem svađalačko minusarenje.

(mcn)

Zar danas još niste bili na www.darkomacan.com ? *** Moje aukcije: http://www.stripovi.com/index.asp?page=auction-search&Action=1&Seller=mcn
Go to Top of Page

zorglub
Average Member



Serbia
529 Posts

Member since 02/09/2008

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 12:50:30  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send zorglub a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by trolodtroje
Robert Benton (2 boda) Rommel



Gledao si sigurno Kramer protiv Kramera. Ja bih ti preporučio pre svega Nobody's Fool, sa odličnim Paulom Newmanom, a ni Twilight nije loš.

Odjednom mi se život proširio.

Kupindo
Go to Top of Page

zorglub
Average Member



Serbia
529 Posts

Member since 02/09/2008

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 12:56:20  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send zorglub a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by mcn
Novu igru može raditi netko drugi jer bi meni bila tlaka, a ne igra.

(mcn)



Neće biti recenzija ove godine?
Sviđa mi se da ih čitam zato što uvek ostaje pitanje da li ti se neki film svideo ili ne. Jedine direktne pohvale se sećam za Incendies, koga je meni ubio banalan završetak. Naravno, kad popljuješ neki film onda dileme nema. :)

Odjednom mi se život proširio.

Kupindo

Edited by - zorglub on 16/01/2013 12:56:59
Go to Top of Page

mcn
Advanced Member



Croatia
6666 Posts

Member since 28/12/2002

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 13:51:07  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit mcn's Homepage  Send mcn a Private Message  Reply with Quote
>Neće biti recenzija ove godine?

Zasad ne. Moram malo reducirati samonametnute obaveze kako bih stigao obaviti one za pare.

Drago mi je što su ti se sviđale.

(mcn)

Zar danas još niste bili na www.darkomacan.com ? *** Moje aukcije: http://www.stripovi.com/index.asp?page=auction-search&Action=1&Seller=mcn
Go to Top of Page

tinton
stripovi.com suradnik

United Kingdom
19799 Posts

Member since 23/10/2011

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 14:38:43  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send tinton a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Neznam jesam li lud, ali čini mi se da Forman ima pet bodova

Dajte nam Banija Libre;može i mekokoricen (ali u boji obavezno)!
Go to Top of Page

mcn
Advanced Member



Croatia
6666 Posts

Member since 28/12/2002

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 14:49:18  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit mcn's Homepage  Send mcn a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by tinton

Neznam jesam li lud, ali čini mi se da Forman ima pet bodova



Ja nisam dovoljno lud da brojim ponovo.

(mcn)

Zar danas još niste bili na www.darkomacan.com ? *** Moje aukcije: http://www.stripovi.com/index.asp?page=auction-search&Action=1&Seller=mcn
Go to Top of Page

tinton
stripovi.com suradnik

United Kingdom
19799 Posts

Member since 23/10/2011

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 14:55:03  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send tinton a Private Message  Reply with Quote
onda samo upiši pet,

ja sam da o prijedlog - 1 bod
ja sam mu ponovno dao plus - 2 boda
rommel mu je dao plus - 3 boda
ja sam mu opet dao plus - 4 boda
Darth Ivan mu je dao plus - 5 bodova


Dajte nam Banija Libre;može i mekokoricen (ali u boji obavezno)!
Go to Top of Page

mcn
Advanced Member



Croatia
6666 Posts

Member since 28/12/2002

Posted - 16/01/2013 : 14:57:16  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit mcn's Homepage  Send mcn a Private Message  Reply with Quote
I trolodtroje mu je dao minus.

S obzirom da si me natjerao da gubim vrijeme na provjeru i time se deklarirao kao smor, ideš na ignore listu. Pa-pa, tintone.

mcn

Zar danas još niste bili na www.darkomacan.com ? *** Moje aukcije: http://www.stripovi.com/index.asp?page=auction-search&Action=1&Seller=mcn
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 7 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Previous Page | Next Page
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Jump To:
forum.stripovi.com © 2000-2002 Snitz Communications Go To Top Of Page
This page was generated in 0.3 seconds. Snitz Forums 2000