forum.stripovi.com
forum.stripovi.com
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Active Polls | Aukcije | Private Messages | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Stripovi
 Stripovi
 S.COM TOP 100 scenarista (rezultati u 1.postu)
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Previous Page | Next Page
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic
Page: of 25

alexts
Advanced Member



Serbia
8141 Posts

Member since 25/09/2005

Posted - 03/10/2024 : 13:28:48  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send alexts a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Ja nisam ni znao da pišeš scenarije.

Šalu na stranu, originalnog Peyoa nisam glasao, samo što ne znam koji je zaista njegov udeo u pisanju stripova.

Kao i Rejmond ili Gotfredson u prethodnom glasanju.
Go to Top of Page

Ernie Pike
Senior Member



Croatia
2851 Posts

Member since 06/03/2012

Posted - 03/10/2024 : 15:47:52  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Ernie Pike a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Peyo, čekamo tvoju listu
Go to Top of Page

Peyo
Advanced Member



Croatia
10375 Posts

Member since 28/10/2005

Posted - 03/10/2024 : 16:19:30  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Peyo a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Ernie Pike

Peyo, čekamo tvoju listu



Malo sam u gužvi, stavit ću je uskoro, samo da ju posložim da mi netko bitan ne ispadne.

Bit će neki mix corto33, dovlajoeove, tvoje i alextzove. Znači, klasika bez nekih iznenađenja.
Go to Top of Page

Peyo
Advanced Member



Croatia
10375 Posts

Member since 28/10/2005

Posted - 03/10/2024 : 16:27:09  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Peyo a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by alexts

Ja nisam ni znao da pišeš scenarije.

Šalu na stranu, originalnog Peyoa nisam glasao, samo što ne znam koji je zaista njegov udeo u pisanju stripova.




Peyo je velikan BD-a i scenarist brojnih epizoda, a scenarije je pisao i za druge. Iako stoji to što si napisao da je kad imaš studio s brojnim suradnicima upitno koliki je njihov udio.
Go to Top of Page

dovlajoe
Junior Member



Serbia
381 Posts

Member since 11/01/2019

Posted - 03/10/2024 : 20:17:43  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send dovlajoe a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by don_draper

quote:
Originally posted by naker

Draperu, što si dozvolio da Hugo Pratt bude nominovan u ovoj kategoriji?



Siroke sam ruke, sto reci. Izgleda da ce se on boriti u dvije kategorije.


Draperu, napravio sam propust ne zapazivši Pratta u nominacijama. Da li mogu da iskoristim džokera i naknadno ubacim Pratta na svoju listu?
Go to Top of Page

alexts
Advanced Member



Serbia
8141 Posts

Member since 25/09/2005

Posted - 03/10/2024 : 21:47:09  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send alexts a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Ma koje to stripove Prat nije izvorno radio za italijanske i argentinske revije, nego za franko-belgijske albume?
Go to Top of Page

don_draper
Advanced Member



4392 Posts

Member since 08/06/2018

Posted - 03/10/2024 : 22:58:59  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send don_draper a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by dovlajoe

quote:
Originally posted by don_draper

quote:
Originally posted by naker

Draperu, što si dozvolio da Hugo Pratt bude nominovan u ovoj kategoriji?



Siroke sam ruke, sto reci. Izgleda da ce se on boriti u dvije kategorije.


Draperu, napravio sam propust ne zapazivši Pratta u nominacijama. Da li mogu da iskoristim džokera i naknadno ubacim Pratta na svoju listu?



Mozes, zamijeni poziciju s nekim pa cu pribrojiti

I sell the fact that I can't be bought
Go to Top of Page

dovlajoe
Junior Member



Serbia
381 Posts

Member since 11/01/2019

Posted - 03/10/2024 : 23:12:43  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send dovlajoe a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by alexts

Ma koje to stripove Prat nije izvorno radio za italijanske i argentinske revije, nego za franko-belgijske albume?


Ni ja nisam očekivao Pratta ovde, zato i nisam zapazio kad ga je neko nominovao pri kraju nominacija. Ako je već nominovan ovde, moram ga staviti na listu, jer možda zbog toga neće biti nominovan u "svojoj" kategoriji. U svakom slučaju ovo smo morali raspraviti ranije.

Edited by - dovlajoe on 04/10/2024 04:30:53
Go to Top of Page

dovlajoe
Junior Member



Serbia
381 Posts

Member since 11/01/2019

Posted - 04/10/2024 : 04:56:21  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send dovlajoe a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by dovlajoe

18 Goscinny, René
16 Charlier, Jean-Michel
14 Greg
12 Franquin, André
11 Marcel Remacle
10 Hugo Pratt
9 Moebius – Giraud, Jean
8 Hermann
7 Jean Van Hamme
6 Joseph Gillain - Jijé
5 Raymond Macherot
4 Alejandro Jodorowsky
3 Hergé
2 Claude De Ribaupierr - Derib
1 Manu Larcenet



Izmene: Hugo Pratt 10, Claude De Ribaupierr - Derib 2 umesto 10, Lewis Trondheim ispao sa liste, 0 umesto 2.

Go to Top of Page

naker
Advanced Member



4628 Posts

Member since 05/06/2020

Posted - 04/10/2024 : 07:49:01  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send naker a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Micheluzzi, Battaglia, Toppi, Pratt.

Goscinny, Hergé, Peyo, Pratt.


Izbacite uljeza.
Go to Top of Page

Shuckey
Average Member



Croatia
731 Posts

Member since 18/12/2008

Posted - 04/10/2024 : 08:25:30  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Shuckey a Private Message  Reply with Quote
18 Greg jer je bio najbolji i to je znao
16 René Goscinny ne mogu ga staviti niže jer nisam objektivan
14 Lewis Trondheim ne podnosim ni njega ni njegovu prepotentnu guzicu, ali mogu vidjeti da je vrhunski pa sam ovdje objektivan
12 Jean Van Hamme nikad nije razočarao
11 André Franquin najsmješniji
10 Hergé objektivno na uvredljivo niskom mjestu
9 Alejandro Jodorowsky zažmirim li na boleštinu otkrivam priču, zabavu, ljubav i likove
8 Hermann ne žali ni za čime, suze nit' lije nit' ih zaziva
7 Jean-Michel Charlier legenda
6 Fabien Nury da se realističan BD othrvao seksu i nasilju, Nury bi danas njime vladao
5 Jean-Claude Fournier jer je volio Spiroua i jer je crtao marljivije nego je trebao
4 Philippe Vandevelde (Tome) zbog Spiroua, velikog i malog
3 Enki Bilal idemo uguzit' jednog auteura na listu ne bismo li ispali pametniji
2 Peyo da me se kći ne odrekne
1 Hubert jer je don_draper bio siguran da mogu staviti još jednog pa da ih bude petnaest

Hrvoje Bratanic AKA Šuki

Edited by - Shuckey on 05/10/2024 01:44:17
Go to Top of Page

Tonto
Advanced Member



8348 Posts

Member since 11/02/2012

Posted - 04/10/2024 : 08:54:54  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Tonto a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Shuckey

18 Greg jer je bio najbolji i to je znao


Konacno jedan covjek na topicu koji razumije strip.

The less I have the more I am a happy man
Go to Top of Page

Tonto
Advanced Member



8348 Posts

Member since 11/02/2012

Posted - 04/10/2024 : 09:28:24  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Tonto a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Sad kad gledam ovu Shuckeyjevu listu bolja mi je od moje. Ja sam dao prednost nekima zbog njihove bitnosti više nego po osobnim preferencijama poput Charliera. Realno Charlier je sapuničar, Branko Vidić stripa.

The less I have the more I am a happy man
Go to Top of Page

matori paraliticar
Senior Member



2272 Posts

Member since 23/12/2022

Posted - 04/10/2024 : 09:55:59  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send matori paraliticar a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Kad se pogleda sta je sve radio Greg lista je impresivna (i raznolika?) ali ja sam nekako uspeo da ne procitam skoro nista od njegovih radova.
Kapiram da su neki drugi gutali sve redom kada su se jednom "navukli"
(bernard prince, luc orient, comanche, spirou, clifton, chick bill, bruno brazil, chlorophylle, colby itd)

cini mi da je dosta od toga izdavano od
bookgrob, SA, marketprint a
ta izdanja su retko iz raznih razloga dolazila do mene


Ja se nadam da ce se vremenom izboriti umetnost stripa i da ce sve propusteno biti nadomesteno!

Edited by - matori paraliticar on 04/10/2024 09:57:16
Go to Top of Page

Mr. Bushido
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
12925 Posts

Member since 23/09/2005

Posted - 04/10/2024 : 10:23:03  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Mr. Bushido a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by alexts

Ma koje to stripove Prat nije izvorno radio za italijanske i argentinske revije, nego za franko-belgijske albume?


Između 1970. i 1973. godine Pratt je objavio niz kratkih epizoda Corta Maltesea u francuskoj reviji Pif Gadget.

Comics is any art you can read. -- Sean T. Collins
Go to Top of Page

Mr. Bushido
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
12925 Posts

Member since 23/09/2005

Posted - 04/10/2024 : 10:25:22  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Mr. Bushido a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by dovlajoe

quote:
Originally posted by alexts

Ma koje to stripove Prat nije izvorno radio za italijanske i argentinske revije, nego za franko-belgijske albume?


Ni ja nisam očekivao Pratta ovde, zato i nisam zapazio kad ga je neko nominovao pri kraju nominacija. Ako je već nominovan ovde, moram ga staviti na listu, jer možda zbog toga neće biti nominovan u "svojoj" kategoriji. U svakom slučaju ovo smo morali raspraviti ranije.


Naravno da će Pratt biti nominiran i u sekciji s talijanskim autorima.

Comics is any art you can read. -- Sean T. Collins
Go to Top of Page

izivko
Advanced Member



Germany
12598 Posts

Member since 25/07/2003

Posted - 04/10/2024 : 14:02:28  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send izivko a Private Message  Reply with Quote
18 Greg
16 Jean Van Hamme
14 Lewis Trondheim
12 Hergé
11 Alain Ayroles
10 Emile Bravo
9 Andre Franquin
8 Manu Larcenet
7 Phillipe Druillet
6 Gotlib - Gotlieb, Marcel
5 Caza - Cazaumayou, Philippe
4 Édika - Karali, Édouard
3 Yann - Le Pennetier
2 Denis Bajram
1 Rene Goscinny

Have mercy
Go to Top of Page

don_draper
Advanced Member



4392 Posts

Member since 08/06/2018

Posted - 04/10/2024 : 17:47:35  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send don_draper a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by Shuckey

18 Greg jer je bio najbolji i to je znao
16 René Goscinny ne mogu ga staviti niže jer nisam objektivan
14 Lewis Trondheim ne podnosim ni njega ni njegovu prepotentnu guzicu, ali mogu vidjeti da je vrhunski pa sam ovdje objektivan
12 Jean Van Hamme nikad nije razočarao
10 André Franquin najsmješniji
9 Hergé objektivno na uvredljivo niskom mjestu
8 Alejandro Jodorowsky zažmirim li na boleštinu otkrivam priču, zabavu, ljubav i likove
7 Hermann ne žali ni za čime, suze nit' lije nit' ih zaziva
6 Jean-Michel Charlier legenda
5 Fabien Nury da se realističan BD othrvao seksu i nasilju, Nury bi danas njime vladao
4 Jean-Claude Fournier jer je volio Spiroua i jer je crtao marljivije nego je trebao
3 Philippe Vandevelde (Tome) zbog Spiroua, velikog i malog
2 Enki Bilal idemo uguzit' jednog auteura na listu ne bismo li ispali pametniji
1 Peyo da me se kći ne odrekne



Siguran sam da možeš još jednog dodati da bude 15

I sell the fact that I can't be bought
Go to Top of Page

dovlajoe
Junior Member



Serbia
381 Posts

Member since 11/01/2019

Posted - 04/10/2024 : 21:54:44  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send dovlajoe a Private Message  Reply with Quote
@anto, @borg, @Peyo, @night, @ken2, @manhunter, @Shaner, @ridiculus
Potsećam vas da još niste glasali za BD!
Go to Top of Page

borg
Senior Member



Serbia
2167 Posts

Member since 13/01/2020

Posted - 05/10/2024 : 00:27:43  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send borg a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Peyo - jer je stvorio savršen svet iz mašte za decu. Jer sam rastao uz štrumpfove. Jer sam ih voleo više od svih zamišljenih junaka.
René Goscinny
Hergé
Greg
Lewis Trondheim
Phillipe Druillet
Christophe Chaboute
Andre Franquin
Jacques Lob
Moebius – Giraud, Jean
Jean-David Morvan
Nicolas De Crécy
Alejandro Jodorowsky
Enki Bilal
Jacques Tardi

Baš nemam vremena. Evo, ovako iz glave. Na brzinu. Malo miksa starijih i aktuelnih.


Resistance is futile.

Edited by - borg on 05/10/2024 00:37:30
Go to Top of Page

Shaner
Advanced Member

Croatia
7307 Posts

Member since 24/09/2012

Posted - 05/10/2024 : 00:44:50  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Shaner a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Aktivno razmišljam o tome da moram glasati već danima, samo ne stižem.

Evo napokon sastavio listu u sitne sate, dok familija spava. Bilo je puno teže nego kod engleza i neki odlični autori su ostali vani ali dobro, neki drugi put će oni upasti a netko drugi izvisiti.


18 Manu Larcenet
16 André Franquin
14 Alejandro Jodorowsky
12 Regis Loisel
11 Cyril Pedrosa
10 René Goscinny
9 Alain Ayroles
8 Lewis Trondheim
7 Timothé Le Boucher
6 Hubert
5 Emmanuel Lepage
4 Didier Comès
3 Fabien Vehlmann
2 Christophe Chaboute
1 Hergé


http://onlineimpressions.blogspot.com/
Go to Top of Page

Peyo
Advanced Member



Croatia
10375 Posts

Member since 28/10/2005

Posted - 05/10/2024 : 13:57:25  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Peyo a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by dovlajoe

@anto, @borg, @Peyo, @night, @ken2, @manhunter, @Shaner, @ridiculus
Potsećam vas da još niste glasali za BD!



Mogao sam se potpisati i na tvoju listu ili od corta 33 ili Ernie Pikeovu.

Uglavnom evo moje liste (jasno je da preferiram humorističke sadržaje):

18 Goscinny, René
16 Charlier, Jean-Michel
14 Greg
12 Hergé
11 Peyo
10 Raoul Cauvin
9 Maurice Tillieux
8 Franquin, André
7 Hugo Pratt
6 Jean Van Hamme
5 Christian Godard
4 Alejandro Jodorowsky
3 Hermann
2 Raymond Macherot
1 Marcel Remacle

Za ovakve majstore nije bilo mjesta, a mogao je bilo tko uskočiti:
Gotlib - Gotlieb, Marcel
Lewis Trondheim
Joann Sfar
Alain Ayroles
Fabien Nury
Manu Larcenet
Emile Bravo
Pierre Christin
Walthery
Patrick Cothias
Jacques Tardi 
Christophe Chaboute
Didier Comès
Philippe Dupuy
Charles Berberian
Moebius – Giraud, Jean
Sente, Yves
Edgar P. Jacobs
Serge Le Tendre
Joseph Gillain - Jijé
Claude De Ribaupierr - Derib
Wasterlain
Cezard

Edited by - Peyo on 05/10/2024 13:58:16
Go to Top of Page

Macon
Senior Member

Slovenia
1459 Posts

Member since 18/03/2005

Posted - 05/10/2024 : 16:48:57  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Macon a Private Message  Reply with Quote
18-Jodorowsky
16-Goscinny
14-Trondheim
12-Pratt
11-Sfar
10-Greg
9-Larcenet
8-Tardi
7-Blain
6-Rabate
5-Hermann
4-David B
3-Charlier
2-Cosey
1-Christin

www.maconcomics.com
Go to Top of Page

dovlajoe
Junior Member



Serbia
381 Posts

Member since 11/01/2019

Posted - 05/10/2024 : 16:57:00  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send dovlajoe a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Peyo, što bi rekao onaj Korzikanac u Asteriksu: Padni mi na grudi!
Go to Top of Page

Peyo
Advanced Member



Croatia
10375 Posts

Member since 28/10/2005

Posted - 05/10/2024 : 17:47:08  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Peyo a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by dovlajoe

Peyo, što bi rekao onaj Korzikanac u Asteriksu: Padni mi na grudi!





Već ranije sam vidio iz tvojih postova da nam se ukusi u velikoj mjeri poklapaju.
Go to Top of Page
Page: of 25 Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
Previous Page | Next Page
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Jump To:
forum.stripovi.com © 2000-2002 Snitz Communications Go To Top Of Page
This page was generated in 0.28 seconds. Snitz Forums 2000