Author |
Topic |
tex2
stripovi.com suradnik
Croatia
29175 Posts
Member since 17/09/2006 |
Posted - 03/07/2020 : 10:02:09
|
4 BODA ZAGOR: Hellgate u plamenu by igor 12
2 BODA CHALLENGERS OF THE UNKNOWN: Challengers of the Unknown Must Die! by Paka01
1 BOD BAJA PATAK: Bajine nevolje by Hercule Poirot
Šteta što se ne boduje barem 5 recenzija, prošli mjesec ih je bilo puno više od 3 odlične, težak odabir!
|
"Od svakog treba tražiti samo ono što on može dati." "The puck is in! The home team wins!", the good ol' hockey game
|
|
|
solar
Moderator
Croatia
21432 Posts
Member since 16/03/2004 |
Posted - 06/07/2020 : 09:35:59
|
4 - ZAGOR: Hellgate u plamenu by igor 12 2 - KIT TELLER: Rendžeri, zbogom! by Spock 1 - KIT TELLER: Četiri godine kasnije by ReemCP |
|
|
Kila Banana
stripovi.com suradnik
Sri Lanka
333 Posts
Member since 02/01/2019 |
Posted - 10/07/2020 : 11:20:39
|
4 poena - ZAGOR: Hellgate u plamenu by igor 12 2 poena - NATHAN NEVER: Gradske bande by Jerry Krause 1 poen - KIT TELLER: Rendžeri, zbogom! by Spock
Nemoguća misija, ima još bar 10 zakinutih recenzija. |
Mili Bože, zašto si me stvorio, što me nisi u kamen pretvorio? |
|
|
DinkoJ
New Member
233 Posts
Member since 09/11/2018 |
|
Altairfan
Junior Member
446 Posts
Member since 12/12/2019 |
Posted - 19/07/2020 : 08:38:59
|
4 boda - ZAGOR: Hellgate u plamenu by igor 12 2 boda - KIT TELLER: Rendžeri, zbogom! by Spock 1 bod - NATHAN NEVER: Gradske bande by Jerry Krause |
|
|
Ernie Pike
Senior Member
Croatia
2629 Posts
Member since 06/03/2012 |
Posted - 30/07/2020 : 12:21:09
|
STRIP ALBUM: Oko Sokolovo by Paka01 - 4 boda TEX WILLER: Otvorene karte by igor 12 - 2 boda KIT TELLER: Rendžeri, zbogom! by Spock - 1 bod |
|
|
Tutta
Advanced Member
Germany
32400 Posts
Member since 19/02/2010 |
Posted - 30/07/2020 : 22:37:20
|
4 boda - TEX WILLER: Otvorene karte by igor 12
2 boda - TEX WILLER: Pero Komanča by tex2
1 bod - KOMANDANT MARK: Otkupnina by Hercule Poirot |
+IN HOC SIGNO VINCES+
|
|
|
Jerry Krause
stripovi.com suradnik
Western Samoa
7008 Posts
Member since 12/11/2009 |
Posted - 02/08/2020 : 15:42:54
|
POBJEDNIK 6. MJESECA JE:
HELLGATE U PLAMENU by igor12
Link za pobjedničku recku:
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/zagor-zg-lu-275-276-hellgate-u-plamenu/2450/
Uvjerljiva Igorova pobjeda u ovom mjesecu koju je itekako zaslužio s još jednom vrhunskom analizom Zagorove epizode. I tu je i nova nagrada u obliko još jednog Fibrinog izdanja.
Poredak za 6. mjesec:
1. Hellgate u plamenu by igor12 - 22 boda 2. Oko Sokolovo by Paka01 - 14 bodova 2. Rendžeri, zbogom! by Spock - 14 bodova 4. Otvorene karte by igor12 - 8 bodova 4. Bajine nevolje by Hercule Poirot - 8 bodova 6. Gradske bande by Jerry Krause - 3 boda 7. Pero komanča by tex2 - 2 boda 7. Challengers of the Unknown Must Die! by Paka01 - 2 boda 9. Tvrđava Apača by tex2 - 1 bod 9. Četiri godine kasnije by ReemCP - 1 bod 9. Albatros by Spock - 1 bod 9. Otkupnina by Hercule Poirot - 1 bod
|
|
|
Paka01
stripovi.com suradnik
Croatia
11442 Posts
Member since 14/02/2009 |
|
Spock
stripovi.com suradnik
Croatia
7001 Posts
Member since 26/12/2006 |
Posted - 02/08/2020 : 17:54:38
|
Čestitke i od mene na zasluženoj pobjedi. Sad sam skužio da nisam glasao, ali nije važno - ne bi to ništa promijenilo. |
Kamo god da kreneš, uvijek si tu. |
|
|
tex2
stripovi.com suradnik
Croatia
29175 Posts
Member since 17/09/2006 |
Posted - 03/08/2020 : 09:36:33
|
Čestitke Igor!!!! |
"Od svakog treba tražiti samo ono što on može dati." "The puck is in! The home team wins!", the good ol' hockey game
|
|
|
Jerry Krause
stripovi.com suradnik
Western Samoa
7008 Posts
Member since 12/11/2009 |
Posted - 03/08/2020 : 12:20:23
|
IZBOR ZA NAJBOLJU RECENZIJU 7. MJESECA (srpanj/juli)
STRANGE PLANET: Strange Planet by Paka01 https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/strange-planet-stp-mog-1-2-strange-planet/2471/
KOMANDANT MARK: Zvezda sa juga by Hercule Poirot https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-zs-1013-zvezda-sa-juga/2470/
DYLAN DOG: Čovjek bez lica by Sarghan https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/dylan-dog-dd-libkb-26a-covjek-bez-lica/2469/
TEX WILLEER: Konjanici smrti by igor 12 https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/tex-willer-tx-lms-3-konjanici-smrti/2468/
DRAGONERO: Koštano lice by Sarghan https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/dragonero-drgn-lib-7b-kostano-lice/2467/
ALAN FORD: Ljepotica Ria by Kila Banana https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/alan-ford-af-ss-414-ljepotica-ria/2466/
KOMANDANT MARK: Ratnici Crne močvare by Hercule Poirot https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-zs-1005-ratnici-crne-mocvare/2465/
TEX WILLER: Uragan u Skagveju by tex2 https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/tex-willer-tx-zs-1061-1062-uragan-u-skagveju/2464/
NICK RAIDER: Otmica by ReemCP https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/nick-raider-nr-lib-7a-otmica/2463/
ICE CREAM MAN: Ice Cream Man by Paka01 https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/ice-cream-man-icm-img-1-5-ice-cream-man/2462/
TEX WILLER: Proteus by igor 12 https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/tex-willer-tx-zs-33-984-985-proteus/2461/
VELIKI BLEK: Njihalo strave by Kila Banana https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/veliki-blek-vb-po-1-njihalo-strave/2460/
KEN PARKER: Božji sud by Spock https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/ken-parker-kp-sa-7c-bozji-sud/2459/
ZAGOR: Put za raj by Djole https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/zagor-zg-vcsp-32-put-za-raj/2458/
MISTER NO: Čuvari divljine by Koresh https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/mister-no-mn-lms-930-933-cuvari-divljine/2457/
KOMANDANT MARK: Pećina Maja by Hercule Poirot https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/komandant-mark-km-zs-948-pecina-maja/2456/
REZIME:
quote: Originally posted by Spock
Broj novih recenzija: 16 Od toga Bonelli recenzija: 9
Po serijalima bi to bilo: Tex - 3 Zagor - 1 Dragonero - 1 Nick Raider - 1 Ken Parker - 1 Mister No - 1 Dylan Dog - 1 + Komandant Mark - 3 Alan Ford - 1 Veliki Blek - 1 ostalo - 2
Očekivano Tex odnosi pobjedu drugi mjesec za redom, ovaj put na "gol razliku". Naime, jednak je broj objavljenih recenzija Komandanta Marka i Texa, ali Texove recenzije su ipak napisala dvojica različitih članova, dok je pokojni Mark ovjenčan novom slavom zahvaljujući entuzijazmu samo jednog, ali itekako vrijednog člana. Tu je još po jedna recenzija šest Bonelli velikana, Alana Forda i Velikog Bleka. Srećom, Paka razbija kolotečinu s uvijek zanimljivim izborom recenziranog stripa i svoje nove dvije recenzije. Eh da, nakon dugo vremena, ovaj mjesec nije bilo recenzije Kita Tellera, ali nema straha. To je samo privremeni zastoj.
Po recenzentima situacija je: Hercule Poirot - 3 (Komandant Mark^3) Sarghan - 2 (Dragonero i Dylan Dog) Paka01 - 2 (strip integrali) Kila Banana - 2 (Alan Ford i Veliki Blek) igor 12 - 2 (Tex^2) ReemCP - 1 (Nick Raider) tex2 - 1 (Tex) Koresh - 1 (Mister No) Djole - 1 (Zagor) Spock - 1 (Ken Parker)
Mjesec srpanj imali smo recenzije čak 10 različitih recenzenata! O kvaliteti istih ne treba ni pričati. Dovoljno je kazati da će opet biti žestoka borba u topicu za recenziju mjeseca. Ovaj mjesec prednjači već spomenuti Hercule Poirot s tri Markove recenzije. Mjesec srpanj je bio i mjesec velikih povrataka nakon duže ili kraće pauze, pa tako imamo dvije poslovično izvrsne i profesionalno napisane Sarghanove recenzije. Kad sam spomenuo povratak moram spomenuti jednu, ali itekako vrijednu Djoletovu iznenađujuću recenziju. Povratak nakon pet godina posta i to sa Zagorom! Iznenađenje sezone u sportskom žargonu!! Ovdje moram spomenuti i Koresha s drugom Mister Noovom recenzijom u zadnja dva mjeseca nakon također poduže apstinencije. Iskreno se nadam da će te pauze biti sve rjeđe i kraće. Po pitanju ostalih, u pitanju je sad već standardna redovna ekipa: već spomenuti Paka sa (samo) dvije uvijek iznenađujuće recenzije, Kila Banana koji je uz standardnog Alana Forda odlučio proširiti svoj opus i na Velikog Bleka, a u planu ima i Malog Rendžera, igor 12 ima samo objavljena dva Texa ovaj mjesec i gomilu već poslanih recenzija, ReemCP još uvijek se bavi Nickovim krimi pričama, a tex2 nastavlja s Texom po planu i programu, baš kao i ja s Kenom Parkerom.
|
|
|
Jerry Krause
stripovi.com suradnik
Western Samoa
7008 Posts
Member since 12/11/2009 |
|
RadioClash
Senior Member
Bosnia and Herzegovina
1670 Posts
Member since 20/11/2015 |
|
Kila Banana
stripovi.com suradnik
Sri Lanka
333 Posts
Member since 02/01/2019 |
Posted - 03/08/2020 : 13:07:28
|
4 poena - DYLAN DOG: Čovjek bez lica by Sarghan 2 poena - DRAGONERO: Koštano lice by Sarghan 1 poen - ZAGOR: Put za raj by Djole
Honorable mentions: Čuvari divljine, Ice Cream Man |
Mili Bože, zašto si me stvorio, što me nisi u kamen pretvorio? |
|
|
solar
Moderator
Croatia
21432 Posts
Member since 16/03/2004 |
|
going going
Advanced Member
Serbia
11344 Posts
Member since 24/04/2012 |
Posted - 03/08/2020 : 22:25:17
|
4 boda- Ice Cream Paka 2 boda - Put za Djoleta 1 bod- Uragan u Skagveju od tex2
Honorable mentions: svi ostali
Ovaj izbor za recenziju meseca je iz meseca u mesec sve tezi. Svi zasluzuju barem po bod, a dosta recenzija zasluzuje i maksimalnu ocenu. Nikad ne znam koga da izostavim i kako, ali eto ovog meseca moj izbor izgleda ovako.
|
|
|
Altairfan
Junior Member
446 Posts
Member since 12/12/2019 |
Posted - 18/08/2020 : 15:48:09
|
4 boda - DRAGONERO: Koštano lice by Sarghan
2 boda - MISTER NO: Čuvari divljine by Koresh
1 bod - ZAGOR: Put za raj by Djole |
|
|
DinkoJ
New Member
233 Posts
Member since 09/11/2018 |
|
Tutta
Advanced Member
Germany
32400 Posts
Member since 19/02/2010 |
Posted - 24/08/2020 : 07:05:54
|
4 boda - KEN PARKER: Božji sud by Spock
2 boda - DRAGONERO: Koštano lice by Sarghan
1 bod - KOMANDANT MARK: Zvezda sa juga by Hercule Poirot
|
+IN HOC SIGNO VINCES+
|
|
|
Dwayne_Looney
Advanced Member
6584 Posts
Member since 15/10/2014 |
Posted - 24/08/2020 : 07:42:10
|
4 - Mister No: Čuvari divljine (Koresh) 2 - Ken Parker: Božji sud (Spock) 1 - Mark: Zvezda sa juga (Hercule Poirot) |
loading...
|
|
|
kandraks
Advanced Member
Bosnia and Herzegovina
3911 Posts
Member since 16/03/2009 |
Posted - 24/08/2020 : 10:50:54
|
4 - DRAGONERO: Koštano lice by Sarghan 2 - TEX WILLER: Proteus by igor 12 1 - DYLAN DOG: Čovjek bez lica by Sarghan |
Dagda, Gospodaru Noci, obasjaj svoga slugu jer on ce zlatnim srpom Druida ubrati Svetu Imelu koja otvara Vrata Nadnaravnog Svijeta...Vrata koja vode do Bogova!!! |
|
|
Ernie Pike
Senior Member
Croatia
2629 Posts
Member since 06/03/2012 |
Posted - 28/08/2020 : 17:06:21
|
ICE CREAM MAN: Ice Cream Man by Paka01 - 4 boda ZAGOR: Put za raj by Djole - 2 boda KEN PARKER: Božji sud by Spock - 1 bod
|
|
|
tex2
stripovi.com suradnik
Croatia
29175 Posts
Member since 17/09/2006 |
Posted - 29/08/2020 : 14:58:52
|
4 boda - Čovjek bez lica by Sarghan
2 boda Put za raj by Djole
1 bod - Strange Planet by Paka01
|
"Od svakog treba tražiti samo ono što on može dati." "The puck is in! The home team wins!", the good ol' hockey game
|
|
|
Jerry Krause
stripovi.com suradnik
Western Samoa
7008 Posts
Member since 12/11/2009 |
|
Topic |
|