Author |
Topic |
dovlajoe
Junior Member
Serbia
345 Posts
Member since 11/01/2019 |
Posted - 26/05/2024 : 18:02:58
|
quote: Originally posted by Tonto
Ovo preskacem. Nema mi smisla odlucivati izmedju pajtonovoca, paklene narance i umri muski...
Ovo glasanje bi trebalo da bude kruna svih prethodnih, svojevrstan plej - of ili finale. U njemu treba svi da učestvujemo, kako bi krajnja lista bila što kredibilnija. I na filmskim festivalima biraju i upoređuju filmove iz različitih žanrova, a pobednik je uvek jedan. |
|
|
manhunter
Moderator
Switzerland
25129 Posts
Member since 17/09/2004 |
Posted - 26/05/2024 : 18:24:50
|
Pa i sâm Oscar u kategoriji najbolji film ima više žanrova, ne vidim zašto bi ovde bio problem? |
I am legion. I do not forget. I do not forgive.
|
|
|
Zula
Average Member
988 Posts
Member since 07/10/2015 |
Posted - 26/05/2024 : 18:39:12
|
quote: Originally posted by manhunter
Pa i sâm Oscar u kategoriji najbolji film ima više žanrova, ne vidim zašto bi ovde bio problem?
Problem je jer se Oskarima nagrađuju filmovi u toj godini, a mi ocjenjujemo sve od prvog ikad filma do danas.
Ne znam jel već bilo, moglo bi se organizirati forumski filmski Oskar u nekoliko važnijih kategorija. Kako koji forumaš pogleda neki dobar film stavi do 10 nominacija za različite kategorija (film, režija, uloge, scenarij, muzika...). Možda... |
|
|
manhunter
Moderator
Switzerland
25129 Posts
Member since 17/09/2004 |
Posted - 26/05/2024 : 18:43:49
|
Evo od mene. Redosled možda nije takav da mislim da su ovo najbolji filmovi koje sam gledao, ali su oni koje sam najviše puta gledao i tim redosledom sam ih i poređao.
Gladiator 12 Some like it hot 10 Alien 8 The Matrix 7 Pulp fiction 6 The silence of the lambs 5 Terminator II 4 Raiders of the lost arc 3 Romancing the stone 2 Shane 1
|
I am legion. I do not forget. I do not forgive.
|
|
|
Tonto
Advanced Member
8168 Posts
Member since 11/02/2012 |
Posted - 26/05/2024 : 18:44:47
|
Pa nije problem. Meni je osobno blesavo birat na taj nacin, ne kazem da treba biti drugima. Samo sam podijelio svoje razmisljanje. Isto tako bi meni osobno imalo puno vise logike da smo birali samo izmedju pobjednika kategorija tako da prvo mjesto ima neku tezinu. Ovako moze ispast da najbolji film bude film koji nije pobijedio niti u svojoj kategoriji. To mi je ono megabezveze. |
The less I have the more I am a happy man |
|
|
manhunter
Moderator
Switzerland
25129 Posts
Member since 17/09/2004 |
Posted - 26/05/2024 : 18:46:24
|
I ja sam mislio da ćemo glasati samo za pobednike kategorija, pošto ovako može da ispadne kao što ti kažeš. Ali ok, igramo se, nije strašno. |
I am legion. I do not forget. I do not forgive.
|
|
|
dovlajoe
Junior Member
Serbia
345 Posts
Member since 11/01/2019 |
Posted - 26/05/2024 : 21:25:00
|
12 The Godfather 10 The Good, the Bad and the Ugly 8 Casablanca 7 The Godfather Part II 6 One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest 5 Shane 4 The graduate 3 Ben-Hur 2 The Shawshank Redemption 1 Raiders of the Lost Ark
|
|
|
izivko
Advanced Member
Germany
12303 Posts
Member since 25/07/2003 |
|
gaspa127
Starting Member
93 Posts
Member since 11/11/2022 |
Posted - 26/05/2024 : 21:53:33
|
12 Gladiator 10 Unforgiven 8 One Flow Over The Cuckoo´s Nest 7 The Shawshank Redemption 6 Pirates of the Caribbean 1 5 Rambo First Blood 4 The Lord of The Rings 1 3 Terminator 2 2 Pulp Fiction 1 Back to the Future 1 |
|
|
ponki
Advanced Member
Bosnia and Herzegovina
3109 Posts
Member since 20/09/2008 |
Posted - 27/05/2024 : 07:38:00
|
12- Unforgiven 10- Balkanski špijun 8- Wall-E 7- Seven 6- Ben Hur 5- Modern Times 4- Roman Holiday 3- Grease 2- Batman Returns (1992) 1- Goonies
Jako teško mi bilo da odaberem najbolje pa sam to najjednostavnije rijesio. Ucestvovao sam u 10 glasanja po kategorijama i pobjednicima kategorija u svom glasanju dodijelio ovdje bodove izuzev u rubrici komedije gdje sam stavio Modern Times kao najboljeplasirani sa moje liste u top 10. |
Edited by - ponki on 28/05/2024 11:26:14 |
|
|
alexts
Advanced Member
Serbia
7598 Posts
Member since 25/09/2005 |
Posted - 27/05/2024 : 11:16:03
|
12 Casablanca 10 Vertigo 8 Citizen Kane 7 Lawrence of Arabia 6 The Searchers 5 Star Wars (IV deo) 4 2001: A Space Odyssey 3 The Good, the Bad and the Ugly 2 The Wizard of Oz 1 Raiders of the Lost Ark |
|
|
King Warrior
stripovi.com suradnik
22289 Posts
Member since 10/11/2007 |
Posted - 27/05/2024 : 12:31:29
|
12 The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King 10 Alien 8 Unforgiven 7 The Thing 6 Rocky 5 Predator 4 Kill Bill 1 3 Highlander 2 Nothing Hill 1 Conan the Barbarian
|
|
|
Ernie Pike
Senior Member
Croatia
2820 Posts
Member since 06/03/2012 |
Posted - 27/05/2024 : 17:03:23
|
12 Godfather 1 10 Rio Bravo 8 Godfather 2 7 Life of Brian 6 Silence of the Lambs 5 North by Northwest 4 It's a Wonderful Life 3 The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance 2 Empire Strikes Back 1 Unforgiven
|
|
|
don_draper
Advanced Member
4181 Posts
Member since 08/06/2018 |
Posted - 27/05/2024 : 23:48:04
|
12 Blade Runner 10 Goodfellas 8 The Dark Knight 7 Godfather 6 SW Empire Strikes Back 5 Apocalypse Now 4 Wall-E 3 Lawrence of Arabia 2 Raiders of The Lost Ark 1 Amadeus
|
I sell the fact that I can't be bought |
|
|
sawitch
Advanced Member
Serbia
39976 Posts
Member since 17/11/2007 |
Posted - 28/05/2024 : 08:06:29
|
12 - The Godfather 10 - The Godfather 2 8 - LOTR - The Fellowship of the Ring 7 - Ben Hur 6 - Gladiator 5 - The Lion King 4 - The Silence of the Lambs 3 - Star Wars Episode IV - A New Hope 2 - Gone with the Wind 1 - Die Hard |
|
|
sawitch
Advanced Member
Serbia
39976 Posts
Member since 17/11/2007 |
|
naker
Advanced Member
4271 Posts
Member since 05/06/2020 |
Posted - 28/05/2024 : 09:20:17
|
Nisam siguran kako treba da se glasa u ovoj kategoriji, pa evo liste "najboljih" filmova jer sam ih pogledao najviše puta.
12 - LOTR: The Return of the King 10 - Alien 1 8 - Blade Runner 1 7 - Terminator 2 6 - The Shawshank Redemption 5 - The Silence of the Lambs 4 - Pulp Fiction 3 - Saving Private Ryan 2 - Goodfellas 1 - The Matrix 1 |
|
|
sawitch
Advanced Member
Serbia
39976 Posts
Member since 17/11/2007 |
|
Cromwell
Advanced Member
Croatia
4248 Posts
Member since 10/09/2011 |
Posted - 28/05/2024 : 11:30:37
|
Slažem se s Tontom, trebali smo glasati za najbolji po kategoriji i to je to.
Ali kad je već ovako
12 - Mad Max 2 10 - Shining 8 - Predator 7 - Conan the Barbarian 6 - Monty Python and the Holy Grail 5 - The Good, the Bad and the Ugly 4 - The Goonies 3 - LOTR - The Return of the King 2 - A Clockwork Orange 1 - Dominion
Btw Terminatora 2 imamo i pod akcijama i pod SFom kao i Lawrence of Arabia koji je pod avanturistički i povijesni. Sorry ako otkrivam Ameriku...😬 |
Bok, kako si.
|
Edited by - Cromwell on 28/05/2024 11:31:32 |
|
|
alexts
Advanced Member
Serbia
7598 Posts
Member since 25/09/2005 |
Posted - 28/05/2024 : 11:34:48
|
Dosta se liste međusobno razlikuju, ovde se najviše ogledaju različita filmska iskustva i ukusi.
Zato je bolje da glasa što više ljudi, jer samo neka poklapanja mogu da dovedu do konačne liste, kao do sada. |
|
|
Tonto
Advanced Member
8168 Posts
Member since 11/02/2012 |
Posted - 28/05/2024 : 12:05:58
|
Dobro, da ne budem partibrejker i jer je sawitch zasluzio zbog sveg truda.
12 A clockworke orange 10 The Hustler 8 The silence of the lambs 7 Monty Python and the Holy Grail 6 Balkanski spijun 5 Once Upon a Time in the West 4 Full metal jacket 3 Blade runner 2 Spirited away 1 Reservoir dogs
|
The less I have the more I am a happy man |
|
|
Tonto
Advanced Member
8168 Posts
Member since 11/02/2012 |
Posted - 28/05/2024 : 12:07:00
|
quote: Originally posted by Cromwell
Btw Terminatora 2 imamo i pod akcijama i pod SFom kao i Lawrence of Arabia koji je pod avanturistički i povijesni. Sorry ako otkrivam Ameriku...😬
... ima i naranča dvaput. |
The less I have the more I am a happy man |
|
|
naker
Advanced Member
4271 Posts
Member since 05/06/2020 |
|
sawitch
Advanced Member
Serbia
39976 Posts
Member since 17/11/2007 |
|
Zula
Average Member
988 Posts
Member since 07/10/2015 |
Posted - 28/05/2024 : 13:30:47
|
Sjajna Sawitcheva ideja, puno izvrsnih filmova i rasprava... Nisam učestvovao u izboru Dječjih filmovima, a neću ni u ovom zadnjem (obrazložio sam). Sawitchu cijenim tvoj trud (kroz cijelih 5 mjeseci!), a volio bih da i ti cijeniš moju odluku da ne glasam. |
|
|
Topic |
|