forum.stripovi.com
forum.stripovi.com
Home | Profile | Register | Active Topics | Active Polls | Aukcije | Private Messages | Members | Search | FAQ
Username:
Password:
Save Password
Forgot your Password?

 All Forums
 Stripovi
 Stripovi
 Izbor za najbolju recenziju 2023. godine
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Author Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  

Dwayne_Looney
Advanced Member



6585 Posts

Member since 15/10/2014

Posted - 04/02/2024 : 12:10:39  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Dwayne_Looney a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Poll Question:
Prošla, 2023. godina je 14. po redu za koju ćemo birati najbolju recenziju. U ponudi su sve recenzije koje su, idući od siječnja prema prosincu, pobijedile u izboru za recenziju mjeseca.

Linkovi su u idućem postu.

Prošle godine je izbor trajao dva tjedna, ali mislim da nema potrebe da se ovo krčka toliko dugo jer ćemo birati i recenzenta godine, tako da glasanje završava u nedjelju, 11.2. u 12:00.


Results:
TEX WILLER: Rendžeri iz Lost Valleyja by tex2 [3%] 1 votes
STRIP ALBUM: Pješcani dani by Paka01 [18%] 6 votes
SREBRNI LETAC: Parabola by drogsy [6%] 2 votes
STRIP ALBUM: Monsters by Wolfman [9%] 3 votes
STRIP ALBUM: Alvar Mayor by Markos [9%] 3 votes
DYLAN DOG: Mater Dolorosa by Salkan [3%] 1 votes
MARTIN MYSTERE: Tridesete godine by prozirna senka [0%] 0 votes
MARTIN MYSTERE: Povratak u tridesete by prozirna senka [0%] 0 votes
STRIP ALBUM: Perramus by Salkan [18%] 6 votes
NICK RAIDER: Nitko nije nevin by ReemCP [9%] 3 votes
DRAGONERO: Osveta by solar [12%] 4 votes
ZAGOR: Božic kalibra 45 by igor 12 [12%] 4 votes


Poll Status: Locked »» Total Votes: 33 counted »» Last Vote: 11/02/2024 11:56:28

loading...

Edited by - Dwayne_Looney on 11/02/2024 12:02:07

Dwayne_Looney
Advanced Member



6585 Posts

Member since 15/10/2014

Posted - 04/02/2024 : 12:11:28  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Dwayne_Looney a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Linkovi za recenzije:


TEX WILLER: Rendžeri iz Lost Valleyja by tex2
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/tex-willer-tx-lib-113-rendz-780eri-iz-lost-valleyja/2955/

STRIP ALBUM: Pješčani dani by Paka01
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/strip-album-kolorka-221-pjescani-dani/2972/

SREBRNI LETAČ: Parabola by drogsy
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/srebrni-letac-srl-drkw-1-srebrni-letac-parabola/2980/

STRIP ALBUM: Monsters by Wolfman
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/strip-album-album-fant-1-monsters/3004/

STRIP ALBUM: Alvar Mayor by Markos
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/alvar-major-alv-fb-0-alvar-mayor/3012/

DYLAN DOG: Mater Dolorosa by Salkan
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/dylan-dog-dd-vec-152-mater-dolorosa/3031/

MARTIN MYSTERE: Tridesete godine by prozirna senka
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/martin-mystere-mm-vec-42-tridesete-godine/3061/

MARTIN MYSTERE: Povaratak u tridesete by prozirna senka
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/martin-mystere-mm-vczs-37-povratak-u-tridesete/3067/

STRIP ALBUM: Perramus by Salkan
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/strip-album-orka-50-perramus-grad-i-zaborav/3080/

NICK RAIDER: Nitko nije nevin by ReemCP
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/nick-raider-nr-lib-28c-nitko-nije-nevin/3109/

DRAGONERO: Osveta by solar
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/dragonero-drgn-lib-17b-osveta/3119/

ZAGOR: Božić kalibra 45 by igor 12
https://www.stripovi.com/recenzije/zagor-zg-lex-92-bozic-kalibra-45/95/

loading...
Go to Top of Page

Dwayne_Looney
Advanced Member



6585 Posts

Member since 15/10/2014

Posted - 04/02/2024 : 12:12:47  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Dwayne_Looney a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Podsjetnik na dosadašnje izbore i pobjednike:

2010.- Alan Ford: SVE ILI METAK by paro
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=38975&whichpage=1

2011.- SAM SAMCAT by Luca_Torelli
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=41396&whichpage=1

2012.- PLAVE PILULE by Mali_Mate
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=43346&whichpage=1

2013.- Zagor: ČOVJEK KOJI JE POBIJEDIO SMRT by Pijani Patak
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=44937&whichpage=1

2014.- TRANSMETROPOLITAN vol. 1 by Boston Jack
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=46339&whichpage=1

2015.- Ken Parker: KAMO JUTRO PRUŽILO SE by Gil-galad
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=47532&whichpage=1

2016.- Morgan Lost: ČOVJEK POSLJEDNJE NOĆI by thekide
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=48539

2017.- Mister No: POVRATAK U NEW YORK by thekide
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=49438

2018.- Nathan Never: ŠUMA STRAHA by thekide
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=50279

2019.- Dragonero: ZMAJEVA KRV by solar
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=51072

2020. - Strip Album: ZATAMNJENJE by going going
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=51972

2021. - MIKI MAUS: Kafa Zombo by Lord Vader89
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=52823#0

2022. - MISTER NO: Novi život by igor 12
http://forum.stripovi.com/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=53706#2555424

loading...
Go to Top of Page

ReemCP
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
12495 Posts

Member since 03/01/2018

Posted - 04/02/2024 : 12:36:11  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send ReemCP a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Puno odlicnih recenzija, pa čak i onih koje se nisu nasle ovdje.

Moj glas ide za Monsterse od Wolfmana, moram priznat da me Wolfman impresionirao svojim pisanjem, za njega sam jedino znao da ima mozda naj kolekciju i prostor u kojem se ona nalazi na cijelom forumu, ali nisam znao da raspolaže i takvim talentom za pisanje. Objavljeno je u kratkom roku njegovih 5 recenzija na sajtu, ali poslije toga mu se gubi svaki trag, valjda ćemo i ove godine dobiti nešto od njegovih tekstova, bilo bi steta da ne bude tako 🙂

"everybody's got a plan until they get hit"
Go to Top of Page

Hercule Poirot
stripovi.com suradnik



12834 Posts

Member since 28/11/2017

Posted - 05/02/2024 : 08:49:39  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Hercule Poirot a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Dylan Dog: Mater Dolorosa, Salkan
Go to Top of Page

borg
Senior Member



Serbia
1709 Posts

Member since 13/01/2020

Posted - 05/02/2024 : 16:25:11  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send borg a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Salkanova DD recenzija mi je usiljena. On se potrudio tu ubaciti i medicinske pojmove i njihove definicije i uzročno posledične mehanizme i svašta nešto kako bi dao na značaju radnji.
Podsetilo me kao kod mene,nekad, na faksu. Ako hoćeš da ispadneš glup, kad te profesor pita šta je uzrok neke bolesti. Kažeš da je uzrok neke bolesti nepoznat ili prosto kažeš da nemaš pojma. Al ako hoćeš da ispadneš pametan, onda je uzrok idiopatski (u suštini stručno rečeno da nemaš pojma koji je uzrok). I tako daš na značaju sebi.

Na to me podsetila i ova recenzija DD. Iz petnih žila se potrudio da ovoj epizodi da na značaju.

Dok sa druge strane me oduševila recenzija Perramusa. Spontana i sažeta. Ono što ja nikako nisam uspeo da uradim u osvrtu na strip. Pa sam na kraju ostavio par nekih nežeojenih rečenica. Perramus mi je ogromna slagalica, gde mi se činilo da ako izbacim ove ili one aluzije ili metafore, da ću iskriviti sliku o delu. Salkan je uspeo ostati na pravom putu. I glas moj ide upravo toj recenziji.

Lepo je bilo pročitati i recenzije ostalih albumskih veličina, poput Alvara, Monsters, Parabole...
Čak mi se i Pakina recenzija svidela zbog činjenice da mu se strip i nije svideo, al ga je ipak recenzirao.
Za Markosa neću da glasam, komercijalizovao je svoju recenziju na kraju :p
Wolfman-u bih dao glas takođe, da mogu dva puta da glasam.

Iskren da budem, nisam pročitao sve recenzije, pa da budem objektivan i glasam za najbolju. Ali ću pobedničku recenziju pročitati, pa taman bila i o Zagoru. :p


Resistance is futile.

Edited by - borg on 05/02/2024 16:30:21
Go to Top of Page

Hercule Poirot
stripovi.com suradnik



12834 Posts

Member since 28/11/2017

Posted - 08/02/2024 : 11:21:44  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Hercule Poirot a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Up.
Go to Top of Page

borg
Senior Member



Serbia
1709 Posts

Member since 13/01/2020

Posted - 08/02/2024 : 11:30:30  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send borg a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Ima više kandidovanih recenzija nego glasova.
Čini mi se da ne glasaju čak ni ljudi koji se bave oko recenzija... Ili se čuvaju glasovi za poslednjih 15minuta kako bi pobeda bila zagarantovana?

Resistance is futile.
Go to Top of Page

Salkan
Junior Member



Bosnia and Herzegovina
450 Posts

Member since 20/01/2021

Posted - 08/02/2024 : 11:37:24  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Salkan a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Ja ne glasam od decembra - ni mjesečno, a bogme ni ovdje za godišnjak.
Pogotovo nisam nikad taktizirao u glasanju, to je valjda ispod časti.


Škafiškafnjak

Edited by - Salkan on 08/02/2024 11:40:20
Go to Top of Page

paro
stripovi.com suradnik



Croatia
8372 Posts

Member since 30/03/2005

Posted - 09/02/2024 : 11:56:18  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Visit paro's Homepage  Send paro a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Pješčani dani by Paka01.

There he goes. One of God's own prototypes. A high-powered mutant of some kind never even considered for mass production. Too weird to live, and too rare to die.
Go to Top of Page

Jerry Krause
stripovi.com suradnik



Western Samoa
7008 Posts

Member since 12/11/2009

Posted - 09/02/2024 : 12:32:51  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Jerry Krause a Private Message  Reply with Quote
quote:
Originally posted by paro

Pješčani dani by Paka01.


Također.
Go to Top of Page

Ernie Pike
Senior Member



Croatia
2629 Posts

Member since 06/03/2012

Posted - 09/02/2024 : 15:53:38  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Ernie Pike a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Parabola by drogsy
Go to Top of Page

Dwayne_Looney
Advanced Member



6585 Posts

Member since 15/10/2014

Posted - 11/02/2024 : 12:03:44  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send Dwayne_Looney a Private Message  Reply with Quote
Nakon tjedan dana glasanja dvije recenzije imaju isti broj bodova. Pobjednika ćemo odlučiti topicom "licem u lice" kojega ću ubrzo otvoriti.

loading...
Go to Top of Page

anto
Advanced Member



Serbia
20703 Posts

Member since 29/06/2008

Posted - 11/02/2024 : 16:07:24  Show Profile Show Extended Profile  Send anto a Private Message  Reply with Quote
uf,sad tek videh ovo takmičenje - za mene je bez ikakvog dvoumljenja,ubedljivo najbolja Vukova recenzija Čudovišta.

Dajte nam Ralph Azhama;može i mekokoricen (ali u boji obavezno)!
Go to Top of Page
  Previous Topic Topic Next Topic  
 New Topic New Poll New Poll
 Reply to Topic
Jump To:
forum.stripovi.com © 2000-2002 Snitz Communications Go To Top Of Page
This page was generated in 0.16 seconds. Snitz Forums 2000